Fullmetal Alchemist Volumes 1 & 2

By Hiromu Arakawa. Released in Japan by Square Enix, serialization ongoing in the magazine Shonen Gangan. Released in North America by Viz.

Sometimes, you just get behind, and have to play catch up. Maybe other series hold your purse more. Maybe you got sick of the ship wars and take a break from fandom for a while. Or maybe you read something that freaked you out, and you just couldn’t go on as you kept thinking about THE SCARY THING.

But, time passes, and your tastes change. And so you go back to remember what it was you first loved. And that’s what I’m doing now with Fullmetal Alchemist, one of the best shonen titles currently being published, and which I accidentally kinda got 21 volumes behind on, and I fell behind on the anime as well (like 7 years behind – I keep meaning to watch Brotherhood). However, I’ve remained active in the fandom, and the chatter has gotten big enough that I wanted to go back and do some mass reading.

(If you don’t know how you can be active in a fandom without actually reading or watching any of the source material, boy, are *you* new to the Internet.)

So, for the uninitiated, Fullmetal Alchemist, or FMA, is a fantasy action series about two young teenage boys searching for the Philosopher’s Stone. Due to an alchemy experiment gone horribly wrong (get used to that phrase throughout this series), the younger brother, Alphonse, is merely a living suit of armor with a soul, and the older brother, Edward, is short. Oh yeah, and he’s missing an arm and a leg as well, replacing them with robotic ‘automail’. They travel around, trying to track down leads, occasionally righting wrongs, and taking a lot of umbrage at having his size made fun of. (OK, that last one is just Ed.)

Volume 1 start off with what appear to be a few stand-alone chapters, with Ed and Al battling corrupt priests, corrupt military officers, and normal boring old train robbers. We do meet two of the series’ villains, Lust and Gluttony, and aren’t they just creepy as heck. Most importantly, this series lets you know right off the bat that it is not Shonen Jump – there will be death, and blood, and so you’d better get used to it. Shonen Gangan is for the *older* boy. We also meet, at the end, the goofy Colonel that Ed reports to, Roy Mustang, and his stoic Lieutenant Riza Hawkeye. Far more on them later.

Volume 2 gives us another running plot, as a man is running around killing State Alchemists. To be fair, the Alchemist we see him kill here really was an utter scumbag, but still, vigilantes are bad! Chapter 5, by the way, is the series’ first really nightmarish one, and was the main reason I paused in both the manga and the anime. Those who’ve read it will know exactly what I mean. The vigilante, Scar, then goes after Ed, and manages to utterly annihilate his automail arm before the cavalry arrives. We also meet more of the military, including one of the most ludicrously silly men in the entire series, Alex Armstrong, and another, as yet unnamed villain. (Given his cohorts are Lust and Gluttony, I think I can take a few guesses at what he might be called.)

FMA has a very good balance between action, drama, exposition, and humor. And there’s several bits in the two volumes that are really rather scary – I wouldn’t show this to anyone under 12, that’s for sure. Oh yes, and since the manga is drawn by a woman, I am pleased to see several strong female characters in here – both good (Hawkeye) and bad (Lust). An excellent series for those who like thrills and fights with a good dose of backstory intrigue.

Excel Saga Volume 6

By Rikdo Koshi. Released in Japan by Shonen Gahosha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Young King OURS. Released in North America by Viz.

We pick up on this volume of Excel Saga where the last one left off, with Excel and Hyatt going back to base to apologize for screwing up the package delivery. Unfortunately, when they get there, they find base isn’t there anymore – there’s just a blank wall. Excel goes to search for alternate entrances, while Hyatt just sits there… luckily for Hyatt, as a secret entrance soon makes itself known. Hyatt finally goes to get Excel, and all seems to be back to normal, though notably Il Palazzo is no longer wearing his long white robe, but simply a black military uniform. It’s implied here that the suppressed alternate personality that’s been talking to him in his head may have emerged to take over.

Meanwhile, Ropponmatsu (loli version) moves into the apartments, much to the horror of Iwata, who starts trying to drive her off almost immediately. (As a side note, this volume came out right about as the anime was finishing, and there are several anime in-jokes in it, notably seeing Excel (voice actress: Kotono Mitsuishi) trying to dress as Sailor Moon, with mosaicing over the costume to avoid lawsuits from nice Kodansha peoples.)

The next chapter is pure wacky, as Ropponmatsu invites her fellow employees out to lunch (at their cost) to celebrate her joining the agency. Sadly, they end up lunching at the same restaurant Excel and Hyatt are working at, a restaurant that misordered and thus needs to get rid of a lot of chicken fast (dangerous for a steakhouse), and having a problem with roaches. The highlight of the chapter is the owner telling Excel to be sure to call any roach she sees Taro-san, so as not to alert the customers. Having been unable to push the chicken on beef-loving Iwata, Excel is forced to go out and butcher a bull four times her size. Naturally, the bull goes on a rampage and destroys the restaurant. (Nice bit where Misaki, who had been in the bathroom and thus avoided the carnage, admits her luck is a bit scary. She managed to avoid the snowstorm in the previous volume as well.)

The next chapter is mostly a day in the life chapter, dealing with Ropponmatsu trying to sneak into Misaki’s room (and getting it wrong twice), Excel and Hyatt’s general poverty, and Kabapu showing us all the joy of a good workout. The most notable thing here is the beginning of the chapter, which begins with Il Palazzo ranting about nuclear power. This is a hot-button issue in Japan, and after Il Palazzo says that he feels nuclear accidents are irrelevant, The Will Of The Universe appears to reset the chapter and turn it into the slice-of-life we get. This is Will Of The Universe’s only manga appearance, also here as a shout out to the anime.

After Excel is almost hit by ANOTHER car (that makes 3 in 3 volumes, for those counting), and a title page shot of her dressed once more as Maki Umezaki from Geobreeders, we see them trying to rescue a young, airheaded girl from some shady yakuza types. Naturally, the shady yakuza types are actually her servants, trying to locate the lost girl, and Excel and Hyatt are now kidnappers. It all works out well in the end, however, and we get the glorious image of Excel hurling Hyatt off the edge of a high-rise and then following her down, as well as creepy Dr. Shiouji showing his love for 6-year-olds once again.

The next chapter takes us once again, deep into Excel’s insecurities. She accidentally eats some of Hyatt’s food at breakfast, and winds up in a drug-induced series of hallucinations. Hyatt gets replaced with an infinite number of robot doubles (which end up coughing up oil, collapsing, and exploding – no change there), and Il Palazzo says that it’s time for ACROSS to gain another member. Excel is horrified over this, and we note once more her absolute paranoia at other people horning in on her Il Palazzo. Her combination of utter devotion and repressed self-hatred can be difficult to watch at times. This turned out to just be a dream, but the need for a new member of ACROSS will come up again in Volume 7.

Meanwhile, Ropponmatsu (loli version) is having a few bugs, and thus has to go back to Shiouji’s lab for a bit. So we welcome back Ropponmatsu (adult version), much to Iwata’s delight. She doesn’t last long, though, as when they walk out of the building they are interrupted by Excel and Hyatt, who had been window cleaning about 25 stories up, plummeting to Earth after their platform snapped. Ropponmatsu catches both of them in her arms and then flip-kicks the platform out of harm’s way. It’s pretty badass, though she notes that it has affected her legs a bit, so she’s not indestructible. She then notices that Hyatt has fallen over dead, and bugs Excel to start resuscitating her.

This leads to the most interesting part of the volume. Excel reaches out to indicate that Hyatt being dead is nothing to worry about, and grabs Ropponmatsu’s shoulder as their eyes meet. There’s a crackle, and we then get a 2-page spread of Il Palazzo and Kabapu, in their respective home bases, looking at the city. Il Palazzo notes that it’s “the counterfeit” from last time… and then Ropponmatsu falls over, totally deactivated. Aside from confirming that Kabapu and Il Palazzo basically monitor their minions constantly, this also shows that Excel is somehow connected to Ropponmatsu, and apparently has the ability to deactivate her. This becomes far more important in Volume 14 and later.

However, back to reality… Excel now has a dead partner *and* a dead robot to worry about. Hyatt wakes up easily enough, but getting Ropponmatsu back online proves to be more than the two of them can bear. (I note that neither one are aware Ropponmatsu is a robot – they just think she’s a really heavy girl.) They put her in the wheelbarrow to cart off to the hospital… but the barrow ends up getting loose and colliding with a tanker truck. Whoops. Excel and Hyatt flee the ensuing explosion, but fear not – A fiery death was just what was needed to revive Ropponmatsu, who stands in the middle of the conflagration, mostly unharmed. (I say mostly as when she appears the following day, she accidentally shifts into the personality of her loli self, something that’s so disturbing that Misaki smashes her head deep into a cement wall to snap her out of it.)

This is a good but not fantastic volume of Excel Saga, notable for Il Palazzo’s personality change (though, his two personas being almost exactly the same, you won’t really notice it as much), and for Excel’s connection to Ropponmatsu. It does have one flaw – there are no notes from Carl Horn this volume, only the sound effects and a brief letter column. This was apparently a last-minute error, but they are dearly missed.

Know your Publishers: Japan and North America

This is another one of those general posts, where I ramble on about the industry in general rather than a specific title. In this post, I talk about the various companies that put out manga in Japan, and what, if any, relationship they have with North American publishers. This might help people who ask publishers “Why don’t you get title X”, not realizing that title X is owned by a Japanese publisher who is exclusive to someone else. I’ve written this post before on my Livejournal, but am revising it to post here, even though I know I risk various industry people commenting on how wrong I am. They are welcome to do so, of course. I freely admit I have no ‘inside information’. Also, few Japanese publishers are actually ‘exclusive’; most merely have strong working relationships, a phrase you’ll find me using constantly below.

I tend to define Japanese publishers into three categories: The Big Four, The Mid-Majors, and other. Technically speaking in Japan I think it would just be The Big Three, but Hakusensha is enough of a powerhouse over here that I think it deserves a place with the big boys.

Let’s start with Shueisha, which puts out, among other things, everything with ‘Jump’ in the title (shonen and seinen comics) and everything with ‘Ribon’ and ‘Margaret’ in the title (shoujo comics). They are part-owners of Viz, and for the most part they license exclusively to Viz, with one or two exceptions (Gantz, a Shueisha title, was licensed to Dark Horse, most likely as DH could do a much better job pushing it over here; also, in the old days, Viz let Tokyopop license two popular Shueisha shoujo titles, Marmalade Boy and Kodocha).

The other co-owner of Viz is Shogakukan, who have the ‘Sunday’ titles and everything with ‘Big Comic’ in it (shonen and seinen), and the shoujo and josei with ‘Comic’ in it (aka Shocomi and Betsucomi). They too are mostly exclusive to Viz; the one or two exceptions I’ve seen have been where the author owned his own rights and could choose the publisher (Darren Shan/Cirque Du Freak, a Sunday title being published by Yen Press; Moto Hagio just licensed her work to Fantagraphics; and I think that the Fanfare/Ponent Mon Taniguchi titles were also Shogakukan titles.)

Kodansha is the other Japanese heavy hitter, having the boy’s and men’s titles with ‘Magazine’ in them, the men’s titles based around times of the day (Morning, Afternoon, Evening), and the women’s titles that don’t fit a pattern, Betsufure/Nakayoshi/Be Love. They are trying to start their own imprint in North America, but so far have not really done much. In the meantime, they have a strong relationship with Del Rey, which puts out the majority of Kodansha titles today. They still work with Dark Horse, both with the old Oh My Goddess and Gunsmith Cats licenses, and via the newer agreement with CLAMP. They have also started to license a few titles to Vertical. They used to have a strong relationship with Tokyopop as well, but Kodansha pulled the rights to those titles a few years back. Again, note the exceptions are ‘author controls where his or her work goes’ – Vagabond, a Kodansha title, is published by Viz.

Hakusensha is the largest Japanese publisher that does not have a strong relationship with any one publisher over here, preferring to sell its shoujo (and occasional seinen) titles to whoever wants to license them the most. As a result, three NA publishers have good relationships with the company; Viz, Tokyopop and CMX. And all three, in fact, have had titles that have made their company wildly successful; Viz with Vampire Knight, Tokyopop with Fruits Basket, and CMX, while not receiving much financial success, has quietly gotten praise for much of its entire line of small Hakusensha titles.

That’s the big four, but that still leaves a lot of publishers. Let’s look at some of them:

Akita Shoten has its Champion titles for boys and men, and its Princess titles for girls. It too does not limit itself to one publisher, licensing many titles to Go! Comi, DMP, Tokyopop, Yen Press, and CMX. Akita Shoten also has bought the license to reprint many old Shueisha and Hakusensha titles, putting them back in print in Japan after a long period – and also, coincidentally, licensing them over here. CMX’s Swan, which was originally a Shueisha title in Margaret, was bought by Akita Shoten. They also have the cult ‘license request’ title Sukeban Deka, originally a Hakusensha title.

ASCII Media Works is where you get all the Dengeki titles, including the most well-known, Dengeki Daioh. They’ve worked with Viz, Tokyopop, Seven Seas, Dr Master, Bandai, ADV Manga, and Yen Press, so they’re fairly widespread.

(A quick note that when I say someone ‘works with’ Bandai North America, that usually means that Bandai Japan had the license to the title in the first place, and the manga rights never rested with the magazine. Some of the Gundam titles, Lucky Star, and Gurren Lagann apply here.)

Enterbrain is a new up-and-comer on the mid-major circuit, and have recently made waves over here with titles from their men’s manga Comic Beam. They don’t have much out over here, but when they do, they tend to work with CMX (Emma is theirs, as is King of Thorn). They also just licensed a title to Fantagraphics.

Gentosha is a small publisher who has a seinen magazine, Comic Birz, which has seen some titles over here, as well as two yaoi magazines that have seen even more. They seem to have a strong working relationship with Tokyopop.

Houbunsha has recently found a great deal of success in the 4-koma market; many of their successful titles are based around that, and have spun off into equally cute if pointless anime series. They have a good working relationship here with Yen Press.

Ichijinsha has a boy’s comic, Zero-Sum, from which it usually licenses titles to Tokyopop. Their yuri magazine Yuri Hime had a relationship with Seven Seas at one point, but it seems to have ended.

Jive is a small publisher with only one major magazine to speak of, the otaku-oriented Comic Rush, but it’s also notable as the biggest publisher to license to Broccoli back when Broccoli was in the North American market. Their Jive magazine also licensed the adult Maka-Maka to Media Blasters.

Kadokawa Shoten has a strong working relationship with Tokyopop, but has also used a number of different publishers to put out its titles (usually with Ace in them for men, and Asuka for women). They’ve also licensed to Viz, Dark Horse, and Bandai. There’s also Fujimi Shobo, which is a Kadokawa offshoot (The magazines have ‘Dragon’ it the title); they’ve licensed those to ADV, Viz, Tokyopop and CPM (the Slayers line).

Libre Publishing, which arose out of the remains of Biblos. Probably the biggest licensor of yaoi to North America, and the publishers they work with are many and varied. They’ve worked with Aurora, DMP, and Tokyopop; Biblos used to work with CPM.

Mag Garden has its various Comic Blade titles, both for boys and girls. After a brief relationship with ADV died when ADV’s manga division did, they’ve since formed a strong working relationship with Tokyopop, which I believe is almost exclusive; I haven’t seen Mag Garden titles going anywhere else these days.

Media Factory is a publisher with two small but cult-popular men’s magazines. They also have a large number of titles for the gaming and ‘moe’ market. They’ve worked with Dark Horse, CMX, Vertical, and Tokyopop.

Shinshokan has the magazine Wings, which is not-quite-shoujo, not-quite-yaoi, not-quite-fantasy, but very… whatever Wings is. It’s licensed to Go! Comi, DMP and Tokyopop.

Shodensha has the women’s magazine Feel Young, but that’s quite a powerhouse in women’s magazines in Japan. It’s licensed here to Tokyopop, and recently to Yen Press.

Shonen Gahosha is known here for the magazine Young King OURS (Young King, its parent magazine, is more popular in Japan but its titles tend to be a bit too ‘manly’ for North America). It has a strong working relationship with Dark Horse, and has also licensed to Viz, Dr. Master, and CPM.

Square Enix is one of the larger mid-majors, up there with Akita and Kadokawa. Their Gangan line has pretty much exploded since beginning in the early 90s, and they now have several spin-off magazines. They used to work primarily with Viz, but when Yen Press started, they began a strong working relationship with Square Enix, via their Yen Plus magazine. The majority of the Square Enix titles I see these days are via Yen.

In addition to these, CMX has an agreement with a Japanese publisher called Flex to co-develop titles; I believe that Flex’s market in Japan is for the portable iPhone manga crowd.

That’s all the ones I can think of; if you have a Japanese publisher that puts out a number of titles here, let me know (I admit I’m not as familiar with the yaoi market). To sum up, you can’t just ask a North American publisher to license title X without knowing a) which Japanese company put it out; b) which Japanese company owns it now; c) whether an author controls their own rights; and d) which publishers work with which companies. I hope this list helps you with d, if nothing else.