Too Many Losing Heroines! Short Stories

By Takibi Amamori and Imigimuru. Released in Japan as “Make Heroine ga Ōsugiru!” by Gagaga Bunko. Released in North America by Airship. Translated by Matthew Jackson. Adapted by Hayame.

Urgh. Not only is this a collection of microstories, but the volume after this is 8.5, meaning it will also have short stories. At least that one looks to see original stories designed to “bridge the gap” between 8 and 9. This one is 100% “I wrote this 2-page story for the folks who buy the book at Bookstore X”. There’s nothing wrong with any of them. They’re funny, occasionally cringey, Anna eats a lot… they’re exactly what you’d want in a Losing Heroines book. But there’s no actual plot or characterization. You cannot develop characters in a bookstore-only exclusive 2-oage short story. And I have over 300 words to go. To be honest, I was actually impressed at how dedicated the author was to shilling for the bookstores. Some of them are basically advertisements. As are the short stories commissioned by a local zoo, which work in the zoo’s exhibits. As an added bonus, most of these being for bookstores means that we get more of Nukumizu’s ridiculous light novel titles, most of which are romcoms. Of course.

The cover shows that, unlike most short story books, which usually are “SS” in Japan, this one is “SSS”. I’m not sure if that’s because of the series’ three supposed heroines or what. The fact that it’s a short story collection also means we get a repeat cover star for the first time, as Anna is back, making a heart with both hands… that’s off kilter to show that her heart is broken. I am not going to bother to break down each microstory here, but they are all basically stories sold as extras for the first six volumes, plus two stories written for Nonhoi Park, a 100-acre botanical park with a zoo. They all focus on the main heroines, as well as Kaju, with other girls occasionally getting a look in. I’d say they’re about 80% Nukumizu POV, with a few showing off the girls by themselves. Anna eats a lot in them.

Actually, that does lead me to what was my favorite story in the collection. A larger than usual short story written fro Bookwalker has Nukumizu alone at home when Anna drops by, as her phone has run out of charge and she needs to borrow his outlet. This works out nicely, as it’s her birthday, and this is the perfect time to give her a present that, frankly, was far more expensive than I was expecting from someone like Nukumizu. The present is both hilarious, because it’s Anna, but also really heartwarming and sweet. He really gets her. As for my least favorite stories, I’m sorry, but Kaju’s obsession with her brother is never going to land for me, and so her stories, which were all variations on that theme, were not my bag. Well, OK, I was mildly amused at the one where she manipulates a competition to get a photo of them taken as bride and groom… one which will be used as advertisements all over the town. God, girl, please find someone else.

What about Gondou, for example? Who only appeared here briefly, but is on the cover of the next book, 8.5. Yeah, not happening, this series already has its yuri teaser. In any case, Losing Heroines fans will enjoy this, mostly as they don’t have to review it.

The Condemned Villainess Goes Back in Time and Aims to Become the Ultimate Villain, Vol. 9

By Bakufu Narayama and Ebisushi. Released in Japan as “Danzaisareta Akuyaku Reijō wa, Gyakkō-shite Kanpekina Akujo o Mezasu” by TO Books. Released in North America by Airship. Translated by Alyssa Niioka. Adapted by Vida Cruz-Borja.

I am so relieved that, after many books that were essentially “how is Claudia going to be killed off”, this book is a relaxing vacation sort of book, just as the author says in their afterword. Of course, the vacation is on an isolated island no one can leave, and involves a search for hidden treasure followed by a search for missing people, and ends with a nasty murder, but comparatively, it’s a doddle. More importantly, Claudia and Sylvester spend the entire time together – wh9ich is good, as he has to save her life from certain death at one point. This *is* still Condemned Villainess, after all. We also get to see several other countries, all of whom are vaguely “Asian” in a way that Sylvester and Claudia’s kingdom definitely isn’t. But most importantly, what we get here is a phantom thief. The identity the thief is stealing… is not particularly a surprise, but I don’t think it’s meant to be.

After the events of the last two books, Claudia and Sylvester are headed off to a summit of various nations, to be held at the isolated island fortress Kentron, a church stronghold. The fallout from the late Cardinal Nigel’s being revealed as evil is still reverberating throughout the lands, particularly the fact that he apparently had a huge pile of loot hidden somewhere. They are all there to make contacts with other nations (even Seraphim, who is not Church-friendly but they invite him anyway) but also to search for the hidden treasure. Sylvester and Claudia make contact with a smug, supposedly hedonistic prince, Li Wei, as well as two princesses who are basically “winter and summer” if you put them next to each other. We also meet Marita, a childhood friend of one of Sylvester’s guards. Unfortunately, she and the guard, halfway through the conference, go missing.

The relationship between Marita and Kostas was one of the highlights of the book to me. They’re childhood friends who grew up together, and there is not a single lick of any romantic tension between them. Sometimes friends are just friends. It’s also possible that the romance has all been sucked out of the air by Claudia and Sylvester, who after a couple of books apart are now back to where they’ve been for some time, which is to say they’re desperately trying not to give in and screw each other. Claudia is once again fluffed by both the narrative and everyone around her, with her looks being amazing, her smarts impressing visiting princesses, and her deductive skills, along with her fiance’s, being top tier. If there’s a flaw it’s that the mystery isn’t much of one – it doesn’t help that the clues are laid out as if this is Encyclopedia Brown – “gosh, here’s the way that this part of the island works, I sure hope that’s not plot relevant later!” Also, the ending is a bit grim, to be honest, but also sounds like it leads into future books.

The cover to Book 10 seems to show a wedding dress, but I know something’s gonna get in the way. I’ll be there to see what, though.

I’ll Become a Villainess Who Goes Down in History: It Seems Turning into a High-Born Baddie Makes the Prince All the More Lovestruck, Vol. 5

By Izumi Okido and Jyun Hayase. Released in Japan as “Rekishi ni Nokoru Akujo ni Naru zo: Akuyaku Reijō ni Naru hodo Ōji no Dekiai wa Kasoku suru yō desu!” by B’s-LOG Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Sarah Moon.

How much you enjoy this book may depend on whether you’re reading this series for the plot or for Alicia. If it’s for the plot, this has to be pretty underwhelming. The Laval side-story, which has just reached an epic quest, and promises meeting new characters and getting more world-building is essentially stopped by Duke smashing into the scene and saying “let’s go home”. Likewise, Gill finds that he cannot actually win against the narrative, as even though he manages to miraculously synthesize the medicine that cure’s Old Man Will’s sickness, it’s too late to actually save the guy he wants to save. (Yeah, spoilers, Old Man Will dies, which must be a surprise if you haven’t read the previous book at all.) But if you’re reading this book for Alicia, it’s pretty strong. She continues to try to work “what would a villainess do” into all of her actions, but everyone else can see the real her – and they worry that the real her is going to burn out very, very fast.

As with the previous book, we alternate between Gill and Alicia. Gill is dealing with events at the school, which are still going very badly – Liz figuring out what’s happening may be good for Liz in the long run, but for her factions not so much, and there’s a hint of a larger antagonist pulling the strings. Meanwhile, Alicia, Victor and Leon are going rock climbing in order to get the rare ingredient that can cure spot sickness – which involves fighting bears and boars, scaling impossible cliffs, and then grabbing a flower that’s nestled behind poisonous brambles – and they can’t use magic. What’s worse, the flower turns out to be sacred to the local tribe in the area, and now they’re trying to kill the three of them – plus Duke, who has snapped and realized he cannot be apart from Alicia any longer, so goes to another country so he can reunite with her. Yup, only that reason. He’s pretty obsessed.

There are two excellent scenes and one disturbing one in this otherwise “let’s try to get everything back to baseline” narrative. I loved the side story with Liz, who goes home because she’s depressed only to find her parents adopted a little boy, so she’s been replaced by a seemingly better choice at home and at school. Her breakdown is handled very well, and I actually do like her now. I also liked Alicia’s mind battle with Old Man Will and its aftermath. The “in order to win, you must fight inside your mind against the one you don’t want to fight” plot has been seen in many other books, but it’s handled well, and we get a bit more insight into Will before he passes on – which, yes, means Alicia gets her other eye back. She’s still got the short hair, though. The disturbing scene features Emma, one of the Liz lackeys who defected to Alicia. Her own role in the plot is ancillary, what bothered me is she was beaten nearly to death and surrounded with the corpses of rats. That goes beyond normal school bullying and into the mind of someone truly twisted – and I get the feeling we’ll be dealing with them soon.

Next time we should be back with Alicia at school, which I hope is the same as throwing a bomb into the middle of campus. This is an extremely compelling narrative. Even if the narrative in this book wasn’t as compelling in and of itself.