The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya 5

By Nagaru Tanigawa and Gaku Tsugano. Released in Japan as “Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu” by Kadokawa Shoten, serialization ongoing in the magazine Shonen Ace. Released in North America by Yen Press.

I really have to feel bad for the creators of the Haruhi Suzumiya manga proper. Not only do they have to deal with the fact that the original novels and the animated adaptation are superior to it, but also that the two spinoff manga, the 4-koma Haruhi-chan and The Disappearance of Yuki Nagato, are more interesting than their parent manga. And then, to add insult to injury, this volume boasts on the back cover that it’s the manga adaptation of Endless Eight, leading many fans who are still traumatized by the 2nd season of the anime to recoil in horror and flee.

And indeed, when it’s merely an adaptation, the manga is predominately a failure. Endless Eight and the start of the 2nd novel are covered here, and they don’t get the room to stretch that the novel or anime give them, so they look rushed. (Note: Endless Eight is, like the short story, merely one iteration. In case you were worried.) Also, the art is frankly only okay, and sometimes looks sketchy and unfinished. If you’re reading this manga to enjoy the stories you’ve read and watched before, I’d expect to be disappointed.

It’s especially disappointing as whenever the manga *isn’t* doing a straight adaptation, it shines. The short chapter from the POV of Shamisen (who is, at this point, still a “normal” cat is intriguing, and dovetails nicely with the adaptation of the 2nd novel, where Yuki feels a frisson of recognition when she’s given the cat for the filming. And the sports festival chapter, hinted at but never shown in the novel and anime, is simply excellent, showing Haruhi once again altering the universe to her specifications, but also showing her not being a total jerkass (rare at this point in the series – her development is the point, after all) and some nice moments for everyone, even Mikuru!

Unfortunately, these chapters are surrounded by lesser quality adaptations, and I’m not sure I can recommend the manga to anyone who’s not already a Haruhi fanboy and thus would buy it anyway. If you *are*, however, the middle of the manga will give you a nice bonus.

Gakuen Alice Volume 10

By Tachibana Higuchi. Released in Japan by Hakusensha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Hana to Yume. Released in North America by Tokyopop.

Ah, Gakuen Alice. You and your hierarchies of bullying drive me crazy sometimes. Well, OK, all the time. And yet, you’re still a compelling read. It’s impressive.

First of all, it’s Mikan’s birthday, and you know what that means! Yep, no one remembers and she’s left devastated. Except of course, they’re all just faking it so they can do a surprise party, which backfires as she runs off. Even the cast admits it was a bad idea, but as Hotaru notes, ‘teasing Mikan is just too much fun’. Hotaru fills in as an author voice a lot through the manga, and you do sense that one reason Higuchi loves to draw Gakuen Alice is to think of fresh new tortures for her heroine.

Then we get the main plot of this volume, where Hotaru (by invitation) and Mikan (by contest win) are invited to a special girl’s only area of the school, or, as it’s also known, the ‘pretty girl harem’. And now we get another group in this manga who are elite princesses, and who therefore have honors and privileges above the common rabble. Gosh, I wonder if they’ll bully Mikan?

Things are complicated by a Candy Ex Machina that glues Mikan to Natsume, and Hotaru to Luca and Yo-chan for the foreseeable future. They wear off randomly, and till they do everyone is stuck. Cue the boys being forced to enter that all-girls’ enclave! And yes, Mikan is bullied. But so is Natsume, as you are reminded that while Mikan gets the typical elementary-school bullying that we all know, what’s directed towards Natsume is a different kettle of fish altogether. That’s not bullying, that’s child abuse.

Of course, Natsume also gets to take it out on Mikan, who he occasionally tries opening up to but mostly treats like utter crap. Mikan recognizes this, and finds him hard to deal with as every time she thinks he’s secretly nice he gets irritating again. This is, of course, a standard shoujo romance trope. I give Natsume more of a pass than I would other heroes as he’s 10 years old, however.

There are some interesting revelations in this volume, and seeing Luca and Hotaru look badass together was cool (really, Hotaru in general is cool), but enjoying this volume may depend largely on how you feel about ‘girl manages to get through her horrible life with gumption and guts’ shoujo. This has long been a staple of Japanese manga bullying plots (see Fruits Basket), and the answer still tends to be ‘if the victim is just stronger and cheerful, eventually the bullies will come around to her goodness and niceness!’. Well, I suppose it *is* a fantasy manga…

In any case, I do still enjoy Gakuen Alice, even thought it drives me crazy. Slightly recommended.

One Piece Volume 38

By Eiichiro Oda. Released in Japan by Shueisha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Weekly Shonen Jump. Released in North America by Viz.

This is one of my favorite volumes in the series. There’s so much awesome going on that it can be hard to sum up, but I’ll give it a shot. Franky’s flashback finishes up and CP9 capture him, with Usopp putting barely a token resistance. Worse still, they throw Going Merry away into the sea! And oh crap, Spandam’s back in post-flashback time, and he’s got a leather gimp mask now.

However, things are now going to turn around. Chopper rescues Iceberg and Paulie (and Zoro’s cursed sword) from a burning building, looking utterly badass as he does so. Iceberg then wakes, and has a chat with Nami about what really happened with Robin several chapters ago. We get confirmed (as if we couldn’t guess) that Robin has become too attached to the crew to use and abandon them like she always has before, so is sacrificing herself and the world just so that the Straw Hats can leave Water 7 safely. It’s pretty cool.

What follows is the moment I usually use when someone asks me “What moment sums up all of One Piece for you?” It’s almost iconic. Nami collapses, and Iceberg starts to worry, but it turns out she’s collapsing in relief because Robin is still their friend after all. Then she gets up and heads off. I’ll quote this part in full:

Iceberg: Wait! The Straw Hats are already defeated. What can you do now?!”
Nami: *Now*, you say? This *starts* now! Luffy and the others are fine. They can’t be done away with that easily. We’re going to get Robin back! Hesitating makes us weak. Now that we know she needs to be saved, OUR STRENGTH WILL BE INFINITE!!!

As if that weren’t enough, this is followed by Sanji getting off a quote that makes him look manly and cool, and then sees him discovering Robin about to get on the train to Enies Lobby. Chapter 359 is near perfect.

I feel I should note that there is some great humor in this volume. Galley-La’s reaction to Chopper’s transformations, Sanji’s hilarious image of Robin as a Rose-of-Versailles shoujo princess, the entire scene with Sanji’s note to Nami (note her utter lack of reaction: I once again note this manga is not for shippers), and Luffy and Zoro’s reaction after Nami arrives at the train with a huge bag of meat and sake. Oda can still bring the lols. (There’s one more, but as it’s a cliffhanger I’ll wait for the end.)

With all this done, it’s time to go find Luffy and Zoro, who have managed to get themselves trapped in various bits of the city. Oh, and there’s a huge tidal wave caused by the typhoon, hitting the city. For those who like action, Luffy, Nami, Zoro and Chopper escaping from Aqua Laguna (with an assist from Paulie) is utterly fantastic. Times like these make One Piece seem like a big-budget movie. (I also note that Luffy, escaping with Nami, simply wraps his rubber arm around her torso and yanks her. Luffy is no Sanji. And thank God for that.)

Unfortunately, the storm is so bad that ships can’t get through, and the last train (with Robin and CP9) is gone. Fortunately, Sanji, as well as the captured Franky and Usopp, are on board that train. Also fortunately, Kokoro knows of a prototype runaway sea train that will be able to follow them to Enies Lobby. This leads to everyone and their brother setting off in pursuit: the remaining Straw Hats; Paulie, Lulu and Tilestone from Galley-La; and the ENTIRE Franky Family, including their giant sea horses Sodomu and Gomora. (Yes, yes, I know… look, Viz has to keep this rated T for teen. Best to just smile and nod at the odd romanji.)

And then there’s the end. Franky and Usopp are free, but Usopp is still in bitter self-hatred mode, so shouts that he can’t possibly do anything and stomps off. Grr. But wait! Another person heard their call! He has come to help them save Robin with his awesome sharpshooting skills! That great masked hero… SNIPER KING! Sniper King in general is wonderful, and we only get a brief taste here. Wait till Volume 39, where you find out where Sniper Island is. (No spoilers in the comments, please.)

This volume marks the end of the first part of Water Seven. The next 6 volumes are unofficially known by fans as the Enies Lobby arc, and indeed, that’s where everyone’s headed. Can’t wait for April!