One Piece Volume 35

By Eiichiro Oda. Released in Japan by Shueisha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Weekly Shonen Jump. Released in North America by Viz.

This volume is fantastic, but also heartbreaking in many ways. Things begin to fall apart here, and much of the manga seems to be devoted to systematically destroying Usopp. He gets beaten to a pulp multiple times, called weak and feeble (and it’s implied that therefore his friends are the same), forced to deal with the fact that the Going Merry has to be abandoned, and finally quitting the crew in a haze of rage and self-loathing.

Usopp’s always had it rough, especially over here in North America. Several of my friends simply hate him, calling him the weak crybaby. (They don’t like Chopper either, but he gets a pass as he’s not human.) In a fandom that keeps talking about how guys with awesome strength can beat up on other guys with awesome strength, Usopp’s clever fights, tricks, and constant need to deal with honest to goodness fear rub some people the wrong way. Of course, Oda knows exactly what he’s doing. Usopp’s drive to overcome his weaknesses is his entire plotline (Oda has said point blank that Usopp will always be the weakest crew member), and that’s what makes this volume so hard to read.

Not that he doesn’t get in some badass moments in his fight with Luffy over the Going Merry. Usopp is smart, and knows Luffy and his powers very well. Using his sharpshooting skills, some tricks, and a few dials from Skypeia, he manages to get in a few major blows on Luffy (which puts him ahead of a lot of the villains). Of course, Luffy is Luffy and Usopp is Usopp, so the outcome is not in doubt. Usopp gets curb stomped.

Robin also has a major role in this volume, which is especially interesting as she doesn’t actually appear in it. The crew is continuing to search for her, but all that becomes academic when Iceberg is shot, and he reveals that she was the culprit. This makes everyone suspect the entire Straw Hat crew, meaning that things are about to get much, much worse in Vol. 36. Indeed, the manga ends with Kaku, Paulie, Rob Lucci and Lulu showing up to kick some Straw Hat Pirate Ass, and looking really pissed off.

And of course we meet Franky. Oda loves to draw goofy characters, and Franky, a cyborg who looks like a cross between Frankenstein and Popeye, fits the bill perfectly. He dresses in only a speedo and Hawaiian shirt, he has blue hair gelled up high on his forehead, and he’s accompanied by two identical twin sisters who wear their hair in giant square afros. Never let it be said Oda can’t bring the goofy, especially when it comes to his character design. (I also loved the running gag of Lulu’s cowlick, which migrates all over his head and which he’s constantly trying to push down.)

Overall, though, this was a serious, melancholy volume. And the next one won’t be much easier, as Robin returns and we find out who’s really behind all of this.

Otomen Volume 5

By Aya Konno. Released in Japan by Hakusensha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Bessatsu Hana to Yume (“Betsuhana”). Released in North America by Viz.

This was quite an enjoyable volume of Otomen for me. One of the main reasons being that it actually focused on Ryo for a short period. It’s no secret that Otomen is a manga written solely for female readers, and that the focus is clearly on Asuka and Juta. We see things from their point of view, and hear their internal monologues. Ryo may be the female love interest, but we rarely if ever see what she’s thinking.

Now, I’m not sure this bothers most fans (Ryo suffers a bit from Himawari Syndrome, which is when you’re the female love interest in a heavily yaoi fandom), but I’d like to get to know her better and see how she thinks. This volumes beauty contest goes a long way towards giving us that. Putting Ryo up against a female rival who’s excellent at ‘traditional female’ things helps to show off her insecurities, which is necessary for a ‘pedestal’ character like Ryo to possess. Plus she gets to drop kick heavy Kliegl lights out of the air while dressed in a kimono.

Of course, her relationship with Asuka is still ambiguous. The author is still having trouble handling the actual romance, partly as I suspect she’s more interested in interaction between Asuka and Juta, but also partly as Asuka has now confessed TWICE, and yet nothing has seemed to change. The lack of forward motion in their romance that frustrates Juta also frustrates us, as he’s correct – if you like each other, and have confessed, WHY AREN’T YOU A COUPLE?

But then, the manga is not really about their romance. It’s about Asuka’s struggles with his love of feminine things. The final chapter in this volume has Asuka torn, as his growing fame as a ‘masked beauty samurai’ is starting to open up the risk of being outed to the world – and more importantly, to his mother. Asuka’s mixed feelings towards his father are handled well, but it does lead to a very obvious cliffhanger. Oh well, Otomen is not exactly about subtle.

The other chapter in here is about Juta winning an award, and realizing that his own secret identity is at risk. Juta’s remarks about the dreams of young girls is very telling, and I suspect much of this chapter is a parody of the current shoujo manga market, where it would not surprise me at all if many shoujo artists *were* men using a female pseudonym as a front. This climaxes in Juta’s solution to the problem, which once again could be seen from 93,000,000 miles away, but is still very funny.

As a romance manga, this can be quite frustrating. But as a comedy, it’s really very funny. Filled with likeable leads you sympathize with and wacky sitcom situations (I’m sure Ryo will have to impersonate her identical twin Eastern European sister any day now), it’s a bright and easy read.

Cactus’s Secret Volume 1

By Nana Haruta. Released in Japan as “Saboten no Himitsu” by Shueisha, serialized in the magazine Ribon. Released in North America by Viz.

Ah, another new shoujo manga from Viz. Let’s see, what have we here? It takes place in high school… girl has fallen for a guy who’s very popular… can’t make her feelings understood. Hrm, I wonder if we’ll see an old girlf—yup, there she is. Ah, and will they bring in the smirky guy with a thing for the heroi—yeah, like clockwork.

To a degree, the North American manga market is beginning to suffer from what has affected Japan for some time – publishers do not want originality. Originality, for the most part, does not sell. Publishers want variations on a theme. Cute girl, cute guy, miscommunication, a few rivals, tie it up in a bow and sell it to Ribon, or Nakayoshi, or Ciao. It’s gonna run 3-4 volumes, then you take a short vacation and start again with a different couple. If it becomes a really big hit, you may be able to get an anime out of it. And as you get older, you can either retire or move up to drawing for You, Be Love, and Petit Comic – where you can either write the high school plot with more smut, or make your heroes office workers.

There is nothing, therefore, intrinsically wrong with Cactus’s Secret. The girl, Miku, is spunky, likeable, yet stubborn. The hero, Kyohei, is in the ‘clueless’ vein rather than the ‘jerk’ vein, so you can actually see what she might see in him. The confession is not dragged on for volumes and volumes, but happens towards the end of Volume 1 – and I really enjoyed the honesty of Kyohei’s response.

There’s even some implied backstory, and for once it’s backstory that the heroine knows some of but we don’t. Kyohei was a ‘bad boy’ in junior high, which is when Miku first fell for him, but we don’t really get much explanation here for what brought that on, or what changed him. Of course, this doesn’t help her out, as it turns out that she may have knew about him, but didn’t ‘know’ about him – discovering your love is not who you thought he was being another standard shoujo plot.

There’s nothing really bad here. The art is cute and uncomplicated, there are a refreshing lack of jerks (though that may change with the intro of rival guy at the end of this volume), and the plot is well-handled and, for once, well-timed. But there is absolutely nothing original here at all. You can pick up 10 other Viz or Tokyopop or CMX manga and get something very similar to this. If you don’t mind manga not blowing you away, but just being pretty good, then this is a good example.