Black Bird Volume 3

By Kanoko Sakurakoji. Released in Japan by Shogakukan, serialization ongoing in the magazine Bessatsu Comic (“Betsucomi”). Released in North America by Viz.

I had considered making this review simply one word: “No.” But I don’t want to be that kind of reviewer, and in truth there is stuff I have to say about Black Bird. I will also freely admit that, being a 36-year-old male, I am not the intended reading audience of this teenage shoujo manga.

That said, you know what you’re getting into when you look at the cover. I’ve disliked each cover for this series, and this is the worst one yet. I think it’s supposed to convey a supernatural sort of sensuality, along with a lusty predatory gaze that teenage girls find appealing. Unfortunately, I keep seeing it as ‘watch me rape this young girl now’. Buying this manga after looking at the cover feels like I’m participating in a crime.

The inside doesn’t really relieve that feeling. Throughout the manga, the plotline overall seems to be “Why won’t she understand this is for her own good?” I have a fondness for strong, spunky shoujo heroines in general. (They all seem to be utterly clueless as well, but I accept that as the price I have to pay.) Misao is the opposite, a girl who has low self-esteem, doubts everything told to her, and feels ashamed whenever she’s with the one she loves. I read shoujo to see girls grow up, find love, and become strong. This heroine is being told “Shut up and let me protect you, or you will be raped or worse.”

And then there’s our hero, who is the brooding and sullen type. Yes, it’s clear that much of his behavior is due to worry over the various rival demon elements that seek to take Misao’s power for themselves, but that doesn’t really hold up when you realize that he went through a whole double bluff before informing his enemies that their powers are virtually useless against him in his domain. And then KILLING one of them in front of Misao. To teach her what her new life is like. And she watches the killing, as he’s doing it for her sake.

And then he licks her wounds in the bath to heal them, whereupon they kiss and grope naked on the wooden floor. Did I mention this title won a major Japanese manga award last year?

There is a certain element of fiction that is very popular at the moment. Twilight was the explosion, but probably not the impetus. In manga, the best example would be Vampire Knight. Vampire Knight, however, at least treats its heroine with respect (mostly), and its hero’s ‘I am aloof and uncaring for you’ attitude doesn’t last long. This Betsucomi version of that, however, is simply repulsive. It’s trying to be dark and sensual, but it merely feels utterly creepy. I tried to give it three volumes to see if it might change, but enough. I can’t in good conscience recommend this title, unless you know beforehand that you are the audience for this sort of thing.

One Piece Volume 29

By Eiichiro Oda. Released in Japan by Shueisha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Weekly Shonen Jump. Released in North America by Viz.

We’re still deep into fighting mode here in Skypeia, meaning we’re not gonna get a huge amount of plot and characterization. We do get some nice exceptions, though. And this being One Piece, the action scenes actually have action in them, as opposed to 18 pages of two character staring at each other glaring fiercely.

We pick up with the second half of Robin’s fight against Yama, a huge bulky jerk who’s Eneru’s Number Two. Unfortunately for him, he decides to start destroying some priceless ruins. He quickly learns that one should never piss off an archaeologist. Chopper isn’t as lucky, as he gets taken out fairly quickly by another of the Four Vassals. Well, they can’t all be as dumb as Gedatsu.

As I’ve noted earlier, this is sort of, broadly, a tournament arc. Characters fight other characters, one wins, and they move on to fight the next one up. But it’s not done as a tournament, but instead as a giant free-for-all race, which makes it work much better. And that still leaves time for things like the hysterical realization of what Luffy’s ‘cave’ really is.

I had forgotten how much Nami grows in this arc. It’s set up in this volume, which shows us just how utterly terrified she is by what’s going on around her. With Usopp unconscious, she’s the last ‘normal’ one, and she knows it. And she’s confronted with someone like Eneru, casually taking out her friends, who she knows are miles ahead of her in terms of ability. It’s always nice to see Oda remind us how not everyone in the crew is a badass superpowered monster (Usopp usually fills this role, and he’ll get the bulk of it in the next arc, Water Seven.)

It helps that Eneru really is pretty incredible, even for a One Piece villain. He casually fries Raki, noting that ‘all lambs are equal in his eyes’, and later does the exact same thing with Robin. (He gets the best line of the volume when Zoro points out, angrily, that Robin is a woman. “…I know. I saw.”) It makes a refreshing change from the ‘stay back while I fight him’ mode shonen often gets into with its female characters.

And then, at the end, Eneru is defeated… only he CANNOT DIE. You fools, who thought you could defeat him! And we finally find out what his plans are, and they’re pretty much ‘destroy Skypeia. Whatever can our heroes do? We’ll find out in the next Volume. Still one of the best manga out there.

I Hate You More Than Anyone! Volume 2

By Banri Hidaka. Released in Japan as “Sekai De Ichiban Daikirai!” by Hakusensha, serialized in the magazine Hana to Yume. Released in North America by CMX.

I Hate You More Than Anyone 2 continues to develop its various plotlines. We get more scenes with Kazuha’s brother Chizuru, and notice that there’s something troubling him that he can’t quite talk about with her. Well, he does try at one point, but Kazuha is so wrapped up in her own love issues that she doesn’t notice. Maki gets a ‘love rival’ as we meet Arata Honjo, who has fallen in love with Kazuha without actually meeting her. And Kazuha and Senko have definitely gone from rivals to best friends in this volume, which makes things even more difficult as they’re both after the same guy.

One thing that is both a strength and weakness of this manga is how you can really see the gears turning in Hidaka-san’s head, as she figures out where she wants to go with things. On the downside, if she had an outline it’s pretty clearly been crumpled up by now, as much of this reads as if she’s writing on the fly from week to week. (As I’ve noted earlier, those reading IHYMTA alongside V.B. Rose will note the difference between a beginner and a veteran.) On the upside, it lends an energy and verve to the title, which feels like it might careen out of control but never does so, mostly as we are following Kazuha’s exhausting mood swings.

Maki has settled down in this volume, realizing he went too far with the kiss at the end of Volume 1 and trying to pull back a bit. And now that Kazuha has admitted (to herself) her feelings for him, the title is not quite as accurate as it once could have been. I was also very amused at Arata Honjo’s intro, as he’s clearly set up to be the other guy who won’t get anywhere, but the author is aware of it; everyone enjoys pointing out in this series how pointless his crush on Kazuha is. And, naturally, we get him fondling her as he tries to tell by her small chest if she’s really a girl. Good to see some manga classics never get old.

My favorite part of the manga is how Kazuha deals with realizing that she’s in love with Maki, who Senko also has feelings for. It’s very realistic; she handles it horribly, trying to hide things and pretend that there’s nothing between them. Since Kazuha is one of the most transparent characters in all of manga, this doesn’t work out very well. Notably, she has to be kicked in the butt by both her friend Asako (who tells Senko everything) *and* by Arata, who points out that hiding your crush merely hurts the friend more. Her heart to heart with Senko at the end of the volume doesn’t resolve things, but it feels real.

And then there’s Arata’s older brother, Tohru Honjo. He only has one scene in this volume, so I don’t want to go into his character as much now, saving it for future volumes. I note that the moment we see him he manages to project an aura of ‘cool’ – genuine cool, rather than just trying to be cool. He’s easily the character who sees the most and recognizes the contortions all the others are going through. And right away, he meddles, trying to move Kazuha and Maki closer together. His meddling is very honest and upfront (necessary considering the cluelessness of his friends), and doesn’t seem mean or cheap, the way it often does in manga. He’s a great addition to the cast. He also has bedroom eyes (called ‘droopy eyes’ here). I love any character with bedroom eyes.

Best gag in the volume – Momoka teaming up with the rest of the family to whack Kazuha with a magazine and then blame it on Ichihisa. I love seeing scenes of this huge family, because they feel so real.

The art is messy, there’s tiny little side comments everywhere, and following Kazuha’s ups and downs can be literally exhausting. But I still love this series. If I recall, Volume 3 also kicks more plots into high gear. Stay tuned…