The works of Mitsuru Adachi

Nine, Touch, Rough, Niji Iro Tōgarashi, H2, Itsumo Misora, Katsu!, and Cross Game serialized by Shogakukan in Shonen Sunday. Hiatari Ryōkō! serialized in Shoujo Comic. Miyuki serialized in Shonen Big Comic. Slow Step serialized in Ciao. Jinbē serialized in Big Comic Original.

I’ve been interested in this manga author ever since reading the one small bit of his works that came out in North America, Short Program. Short Program is a collection of short stories that the author produced over the years. There are 3 volumes, but unfortunately they sold poorly over here, so Viz is unlikely to release the third. The stories run the gamut from comedy to drama, and most of them share Adachi’s sense of subtlety.

But short stories is not what makes him the biggest Shonen Sunday author to never get a hit over here. He writes sports mangas. And in general, baseball mangas are his specialty. The most recent of these, Cross Game, just finished in Japan this week after 170 chapters. He’s had several TV animes (including Cross Game, which is still running as an anime), some live-action adaptations, and for the most part has been running continuously in Shogakukan titles since about 1978. He mostly writes for Shonen Sunday, but also for the seinen Big Comic line, and has had 2 series in Shojo Comic and Ciao. What with some short stories running in the josei Petit Comic, he is the rare mangaka to have a 4-genre home run.

The reasons he’s never made it big over here are unknown, but I can guess. First of all, he does sports manga. Sports manga, and especially baseball manga, has a tendency to be viewed as ‘low-selling kiss of death’ over here for some reason. (OK, perhaps the reason being that when Viz has tried sports manga, it *has* sold poorly.) Secondly, his best, most popular titles are long-runners. Touch is 26 volumes, H2 is 34, and Cross Game will be 17. In a poor economy, that can be a dangerous investment. Third, while he can draw some lovely art, he’s not usually known for his artistic abilities, and has been accused often of having his various heroes and heroines look exactly the same with only minor hair variants. It’s also possible, after Short Program didn’t really do well (and had art flipped) that the artist may simply not want to be licensed over here.

And lastly, there’s his character’s emotions. Or rather, their placidness. I don’t mean that during the course of his various series, characters don’t get angry, or cry, or cheer, etc. They do. But overall, he’s almost the anti-Rumiko Takahashi (a good friend of his, who has described him as her greatest rival) in that you don’t find a lot of crazy over the top madness in his series. Cross Game, the most recent, has a tsundere-type in the lead heroine of Aoba Tsukishima, but even her ‘what a jerk! I hate him!’ is pretty mild.

Likewise, there is a romantic aspect to almost all his series, with crushes, rivalries, and the like. But for Western audiences, the lack of ‘payoff’ might be frustrating. Many of his series end with the two leads still not explicitly stating their feelings, choosing to hold hands, or having a kiss silhouetted. It’s meant to be a peaceful ending showing that life goes on, and certainly the romantic entanglements always seem to be resolved by the end (as opposed to, say, Takahashi’s UY or Ranma), but many fans tend to be dissatisfied at the lack of a final explicit resolution. Not all of his series are like this; Rough, about 2 swimmers who fall in love, is far more explicit about its love, mostly as the plot involves a Romeo and Juliet-style rivalry between their two families. But for the most part, if you’re reading Adachi for romantic payoffs, you’re reading the wrong author.

That said, there’s lots to love about Adachi’s works. His guys tend to be genuinely likeable, his girls cute and independent. He has several themes besides sports that run through his works; death hovers over several of his series, with the death of a major character being the focal point on which two of his series turn. It’s not used in a horrific or dramatic way; usually the focus tends to be on those left behind, and their inability to move past the incident. Likewise, there’s a strong family element in his stories, with fathers, mothers and siblings playing important roles. As with many shonen series, there’s a lot of attention devoted to improving oneself; many of his heroes start off as lazy or unmotivated, and end up discovering their passion through the sport of that particular manga.

Where would I start if I were Viz and didn’t care about things selling? Actually, probably with his most recent work, Cross Game. At 17 volumes, it’s long but not too long. It would be a good feeler to see if baseball manga can work out over here. It’s well-written, with several surprises. And it handles most of the themes I’d mentioned above with the ease and grace of a veteran in the manga industry. Rough, which I’d mentioned earlier, is a great manga with a more explicit romance than usual and some great swimming and diving scenes. And Slow Step could, even with its old-school 80s art, slide seamlessly into Shojo Beat; it deals with softball and romantic entanglements from a female lead’s perspective, and ran in their Ciao magazine for 7 volumes.

Crown Of Love Volume 1

By Yun Kouga. Released in Japan as “Renai Crown” by Sobisha, serialized in the magazine Comic Crimson. Released in North America by Viz.

It’s interesting to read a manga that features three protagonists who I dislike, yet still manages to hold my attention and makes me want to read more. Crown of Love is such a manga.

Its publisher, Sobisha, seems to be a Shueisha subsidiary. This manga ran in the late-90s in Comic Crimson, which was then sort of what Cookie is now – a magazine that straddles the line between shoujo and josei. The old manga Planet Ladder (put out by Tokyopop back in the day) also ran here. The magazine folded in 2003, and I wonder if the original art wasn’t saved very well. The art in this volume is good, but gives that feeling of ‘second to third generation copy’ to me. Of course, that might also be the style, which is pretty old fashioned.

It’s also apparently a retelling of a story from the late 80s, Ren-Ai, which ran in Akita Shoten’s Princess magazine. It was cut off at 3 volumes, and the artist wanted to retell it and give the characters more depth. Of course, this manga is only 4 volumes (did it end with Comic Crimson folding?), so I’m not sure how successful she was.

The basic premise of Crown of Love is that Hisayoshi, a musical prodigy and son of a famous classical orchestra player, meets an idol singer, Rima, on a train and falls instantly in love with her. This bothers him, and he seems to be well aware what this makes him look like to her, but he continues to try to get close to her, ripping apart his rather cloistered life in order to do so.

You could argue, looking at Hisayoshi, that he needed this sort of kick in the pants. Certainly his father’s violence towards him makes you realize that moving out is a good thing. Unfortunately, he’s pretty much an emotional zero. He has lots of inner monologue musing on his feelings, but that only amplifies the fact that he’s very closed off.

As for his crush, she’s also dealing with unresolved love feelings, and like Hisayoshi, she is fully aware that they’re not the healthiest thing. Her crush is on the man who ‘discovered’ her. Sadly, he seems to be married. Or gay. Or, this being Yun Kouga, probably both. She also has parent issues, namely a mother that wants nothing more than to sponge off her newfound idol fame. The combined pressure of this plus her career is making her a bit twitchy.

As for Ikeshiba, the manager, until we get a better backstory he’s the biggest cipher of all. (His sarcastic, cynical daughter was probably my favorite character). Clearly he has a mysterious past going on, and his ambiguous gayness is pretty hot, I suppose, if you’re into ambiguous gays. He comes across as a manipulator, though. I’m hoping the two leads tell him to get bent at some point.

Despite my criticisms, the impressive thing about this manga is that I really want to see what happens next. The leads aren’t likeable, but they are human, and I want to see them overcome their problems and find love. I also like the message this manga seems to be giving, which is that you can have as much common sense and intellect as you want, but love will come along and stomp on that and there’s little you can do but try to hold on tight.

Black Butler Volume 1

By Yana Toboso. Released in Japan as “Kuroshitsuji” by Square Enix, serialization ongoing in the magazine GFantasy. Released in North America by Yen Press.

Black Butler was doomed to be a hit in North America the moment it was licensed. And everyone knew it. Sure enough, it’s at the top of last week’s New York Times bestseller list for manga. It has a handsome bishonen butler on the cover! This is to female readers what maids are for guys, one would imagine.

I think the key to understanding this story is in the author’s notes at the end, where Toboso-san notes that she wanted to draw a cool butler, but had no ideas beyond that. And indeed, one of the strengths of the manga is that the butler *is* cool. If you’re going to brag about your manga with an awesome butler, you better back it up. Sebastian is quick-thinking, clear-headed, fights like a pro, and is basically the butler of your dreams, provided you don’t mind selling your soul.

Unlike the other major butler manga coming out here, Hayate the Combat Butler, this series is for the most part action-oriented, with occasional forays into angsty drama. What comedy there is comes from the rest of the staff of the house, who are all goofy ditzes who could probably have their personalities swapped and you’d never know. Their goal is to be the Greek Chorus, screw things up so that the butler can fix them, and be goofy. They succeed. I’m not fond of them, but they succeed at what they need to do.

As for Sebastian’s master, Ciel, he’s a grumpy loli. Yes, he’s male, but that merely makes him a grumpy male loli (a shota). He’s 12 years old, but his maturity level ranges from 6 to 35 depending on what the plot requires. There is an element of not-quite-yaoi here that I choose to ignore, even though I know it’s a major reason this title is as popular as it is. But hey, if I can read CLAMP I can read this.

Not sure I will continue to read this, though. There is one major problem I had with this first book. It reads like the author is connecting the dots of an evil-butler picture book. Every single plotline is so calculated, so designed to do what it does, that you can almost see each piece slot into place. The revelation of what Sebastian really is, towards the end of this book, is no surprise whatsoever. In fact, nothing here is a surprise. Everything happens the way that it was laid out, and while it looks pretty, there’s nothing that made me go “Ooooh, WOW!”.

It’s a good manga. There’s lots of pretty boys, and fights, and the promise of more evil leering grins in volumes to come. But if someone was to write a manga that would be designed to hit #1 on the NYT bestseller list (and indeed on Japan’s bestseller lists)… well, it would be Vampire Knight. But this would be a close second. If you can get past that, you’ll probably enjoy Black Butler a great deal.