By Fuyutsuki Koki and Haduki Futaba. Released in Japan as “Higeki no Heroine Buru Imōto no Sei de Konyaku Hakishita no Desu ga, Naze ka Seigikan no Tsuyoi Ōtaishi ni Karamareru you ni Narimashita” by Overlap Novels f. Released in North America by Airship. Translated by Sarah Moon. Adapted by Veles Svitlychny.
This is a classic example of a sequel that manages to do some things right and some things wrong for the second book. Much to my relief, a lot of the broad humor that felt out of place in the first volume has disappeared, which is good, as there’s a very real threat to the kingdom going on here. That said, the tendency of the author towards writing ridiculous cartoon villains has not gone away, and I ended up calling the main villain of the book Jacob Rees-Mogg, if only as he had a top hat AND a monocle, and his inner monologue tended to end in “Mwa ha ha ha ha ha ha!”. There is an exception, though, which I’ll get to later, as it was easily the biggest surprise of the book for me. Oh yes, and the Chinese stereotype girl? She’s worse. I wish she hadn’t been in it.
After the fallout from the arrest of Jade Berklein, Eric and Leia are ready to do things such as visit the new popular ice cream shop, run by a mage with a talent for ice magic. Unfortunately, while they’re there, Baron Almer, one of the minor villains from the first book, is poisoned, and while Leia saves his life, evidence points to the ice cream shop being responsible. While this is going on, Eric and Dale’s father the King declares that he is going to announce the revocation of special rights to the elite families in the kingdom, and boy are those families pissed. So the King needs extra guards. Fortunately, Duke Rees-Mogg… erm, Algrene, is here to lend the King his crack mercenary troops who are totally not assassins in disguise. Can Eric and Leia manage to save the king? And what’s up with Dale anyway?
The surprise I was alluding to, which… mostly works – I give the author credit for trying it in the first place – is the presence of Jill in this book. No, she is not, as I expected, escaped and once again being the worst. She spends the entire book in a cold, damp cell. But she is visited by someone who keeps asking pointed questions, such as “why is no one coming to save you?” and “why do you think your sister hated you?”. And the lack of her mother or other people telling her how to think forces Jill to think for herself, and you can see the “Are we the baddies?” meme show up on her face. This doesn’t go perfectly – she was such a cartoon in the first book that I found her sudden turn a bit hard to buy – but certainly I like it better than just having her executed. It was also a surprise, which is nice.
The third book, judging by the wedding outfits on the cover, is the final one. This isn’t great, but it’s also not awful, stereotypes aside. Also, given she’s now engaged to the prince, we’ll get the Princess Leia joke soon.