By Chidori Hama and Wan Hachipisu. Released in Japan as “Akuyaku Reijō, Brocon ni Job Change Shimasu” by Kadokawa Beans Bunko. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Rymane Tsouria.

This is a relatively plot-lite book. Apart from introducing the next presumed antagonist (who shows up to be menacing and then goes away until the next book), the main thrust is that, as much as Ekaterina would like to just quietly work behind the scenes and let other people shine instead of her, that’s simply not going to fly. Not only is she gorgeous, smart, compelling, etc, but everyone around her also sees her as if… well, as if she’s the main character in a light novel. When she tries to deflect, people interpret it in the best possible light. Especially her brother. Yes, it’s another volume of Goodbye Overtime so we get a lot more of Alexei and Ekaterina talking about how devoted they are to each other, though thankfully it’s as sexless as always. And for all that she’s trying to do her best to avoid getting a bad end/executed, I think she may have more trouble NOT marrying the crown prince. The universe wants her to be Queen.

This does take place at a magic academy, and even though it’s not Japan and there are nobility and commoners, all that is irrelevant as it’s School Festival time. Ekaterina is worried as she vaguely recalls the game has their class doing a play where she’s cast as the wicked villainess, and she’s like to avoid that, thank you. She wants to do a choir, seeing as they now have classmates beloved by the God of Music. Unfortunately, her classmates have other ideas, and want a play. But it’s OK. She can write it, and, well, direct it, produce it, and stage manage it, but she doesn’t have to BE in it, she can cast everyone else! Flora is the heroine, of course. And Olga is the villain, and will get the big weepy song, as sung by Susan Boyle on Britain’s Got Talent! Nothing could POSSIBLY go wrong!

The highlight of the book is the performance, because of course, something goes wrong. In a world where you have Gods who can literally whisk people away to Valhalla for concert performances, casting their new talent in your play is perhaps not the best idea. So Ekaterina has to play the villain after all, and try to fit into a dress that’s far too tight for her more voluptuous figure, sing a song that requires hitting a few high notes she’d rather not, and also try to remember her lines. She succeeds at two of these, but fortunately not only does everyone adore her, but her desperation fits the character she’s playing anyway. And she’s as oblivious as ever, not realizing the danger she’s in in the student council room, and also not realizing the song she’s ripping off from Les Mis could also describe her own childhood. Let’s just say the sister complex is not getting smaller anytime soon.

The next volume only came out in Japan a few months ago, but seems to continue the festival. Fans of the series should enjoy this new volume.

By Chidori Hama and Wan Hachipisu. Released in Japan as “Akuyaku Reijō, Brocon ni Job Change Shimasu” by Kadokawa Beans Bunko. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Rymane Tsouria.

At last, we are back at the school, and Ekaterina is back to worry about the plot of the otome game. Literally, she is worried that this plot makes no sense. As many other fans of villainess books have noted, if your family is ludicrously powerful, and you are found to have tried to murder a commoner… you’re not going to get the death penalty. At worst, you may get house arrest. But otome games in light novels (as opposed to real otome games, which until recently have rarely had villainesses in them) rely to a large degree on bad writing, which is what makes things so difficult… or easy… for the villainess. In this case, Ekaterina’s memories of her past and ability to use those memories to advance society (or write hit songs) allow her to evade this fate, but just as she can’t see that everyone is in love with her, she can’t see that getting executed is not in the cards anymore. For her, at least.

Alexei and Ekaterina are at last back in the capital, and Ekaterina can finally go back to school, catch up with her friends Marina and Olga, and do her best to avoid tripping any otome game flags. Unfortunately, given she’s the unparalleled prime candidate to be the next Empress, trouble is still going to find her. In this case, trouble is in the form of Lydia, the daughter of a marquess and another theoretical candidate for Mikhail’s hand… though he doesn’t really seem to care for her much. And she really doesn’t like Ekaterina. And since this is otome game world, it turns out that just as art is really important here, so is music. And as Olga’s barony is under Lydia’s marquessery, and Olga has a beautiful singing voice, Lydia discovers a way to make Ekaterina face a very difficult choice.

This is not nearly as silly as Bakarina, but it’s coloring in the same lines, and one of the ways that it does that is that anyone who comes into contact with Ekaterina seems to fall under her spell. In this case it’s not the God of Music,. mostly as he’s found two prodigies, but it is the former Emperor and his wife, as it turns out his wife is also one of the best singers in the country. And, oddly, it even turns out to be Lydia, who is smart but runs on anger and being told what to do by her parents, and after a hefty dose of humility, appears to actually learn her lesson. This series doesn’t like to have villainesses fall, lest Ekaterina join them. On the bright side, romance is resolved here. No, not that one. But Olga meets a music nerd and the two of them fall in beautiful music nerd love together, only we barely see this because the series is filtered through its protagonist, who has to literally be told they’re a couple by the prince. If only he could be more explicit about his own feelings, but I get it. It won’t work while she’s like this.

As long as there’s no sexual attraction, she and her brother can say they love each other and jump into each other’s arms as much as they like, IMO. A good villainess series for fans of “otome game analysis”.

By Chidori Hama and Wan Hachipisu. Released in Japan as “Akuyaku Reijō, Brocon ni Job Change Shimasu” by Kadokawa Beans Bunko. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Rymane Tsouria.

There are quite a few villainess books where I would describe the plot as performative, but Goodbye Overtime really leans into that. Ekaterina admits that these are real people that she loves and not just characters in a game, and also admits that she’s likely derailed things so much that the whole “doom” part of the game is not going to happen. But the monster from Book 2 shook her, and she remains panicked that if she takes her eyes away from things for one moment, everything will get back on the rails. I was startled to hear that she even saved one of the minor villainesses from a previous book, getting her a job as a maid (and the villainess is actually doing it well!) because she sees it as an inevitable future for herself. Ekaterina is very bad at seeing herself as others see her, but she’s also bad at confessing why she’s worried. At some point I think she’ll have to admit the reincarnation.

It’s STILL summer vacation, and after all her adventures across the territory last time, Ekaterina is back next to her brother and hosting events at her domain’s castle. The special guest is Mikhail, the Crown Prince, so all the red carpets are being rolled out. Flora is also there, and rumors are flying. Rumors are also flying about Ekaterina herself, and those rumors might be a lot closer to reality than she knows. Let’s face it, Mikhail is in love with her, Flora is in love with her, Vladforen is in love with her… and she’s completely incapable of seeing any of this, something all her love interests already know. She only has eyes for her brother, and he for her. Though thankfully, it’s made a little more clear that this is not romantic or sexual.

In any case, there’s a party, where they reintroduce a traditional dance her grandmother had banned, and a hunting party, where women are allowed to hunt again as her grandmother had banned that. Really, we see more evidence that her grandmother is simply terrible, though we are also rewarded with the idea that her father may have loved her mother more than she thought. We also see her almost enter into a contract with fairies, which underlines what the other nobles are saying – she may be gorgeous, and brilliant, and a pioneer in business, but she is painfully naive, and one of these days someone will get her away from Alexei and bad things are going to happen. (This is the second book in a row where she’s been spirited away from her main, and I suspect Mina is stressing out about this.

If you think this review is short on substance, the book is also pretty light. On the bright side, we’re finally heading back to school next time, and hopefully we can advance the plot. Though, like Bakarina, this is a series that relies very heavily on romance not happening despite everyone mooning over the heroine.