Category Archives: reviews

Reincarnated As the Last of My Kind, Vol. 1

Leave a reply

By Kiri Komori and Yamigo. Released in Japan as “Tensei Shitara Zetsumetsu Sunzen no Kishou Shuzokudeshita” on the Shōsetsuka ni Narō website. Released in North America by Cross Infinite World. Translated by Roman Lempert.

As I was reading this book, I kept getting an odd feeling, and I wondered what it was. The premise was simple enough – indeed, we’ve seen it before, as it’s very Mushoku Tensei if that were a slow life title. The heroine is sweet, remembering some details of her past in Japan when she needs to, but also allowed to at times be the cute little girl we see on the cover. The overpowered nature of the title is actually pretty tolerable, and this was startling given how many times the main character gets called a genius (don’t make it a drinking game). Then I realized about 3/4 of the way through what the issue was: this book gets to the end of Vol. 1, and we have a LOT of questions unresolved, including the main one about Tina’s origins. It’s the first of a long-running series. And that’s weird given it’s put out by Cross Infinite World, whose idea of “a huge long-runner” is about three books.

The cover is a bit of a fakeout, as I was absolutely expecting this young girl to be raised by the multi-tailed wolf on the cover, and that does not happen. After getting something of a 1978 Superman movie sendoff from her parents (who are about to die tragically), she ends up, after a series of terrifying moments, adopted by Marcus, an ex-soldier who lost his arm in the war and is headed back to his parents’ inn in the country. Naming her Tinaris, or Tina for short, they proceed to have a relatively sedate life, despite the passing of first Marcus’ mother and this his father, and the occasional eccentric guests at their inn, who usually get drawn into what Tina is doing. Because, well, Tina is odd. The fact that she’s very smart for her age we’d normally put down to the reincarnation memories, but it isn’t just that. She has an ability for alchemy and potions that’s off the scale–at five years old! And then there’s her pointy ears. She’s not an elf… but she’s clearly not human either.

The book’s world building is more complex than I expected, and can get very dark. Tina starts the book as a baby, and is immediately found by Bandits, who suggest assaulting her. Marcus has lost an arm, and his prosthetic isn’t great. A colleague of his lost half her face in a potion accident. And there’s an ongoing annoying running gag of everyone asking Tina about romance, despite the fact that at the end of the book she’s still only six years old. (That said, I’m pretty sure this last part is meant to be irritating, judging by Tina’s reaction to it all). That said… the book is still pleasant overall. Marcus is a good dad, occasionally hapless but not bumbling. Tina’s POV is well-balanced, as I said above, between the “woman from Japan” part of her and Tina herself, and she really does have a talent for alchemy and magic, and FAR more mana than humans. There’s an undercurrent of racism towards non-human races from another country, and slavery pops up (though thankfully no one ends up buying a slave). It’s… well, look at that, I started describing it and it got dark again.

There is sweet and fun stuff here, most of which I didn’t mention. The series, though, is clearly not remotely done, so don’t expect the classic done-in-one CIW story. This is in it for a longer haul. I’ll read the next one.

So I’m a Spider, So What?, Vol. 10

Leave a reply

By Okina Baba and Tsukasa Kiryu. Released in Japan as “Kumo Desu ga, Nani ka?” by Kadokawa Books. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Jenny McKeon.

(There are spoilers in this review for the previous volume, so make sure you’ve read 9 first. Or are spoiled.)

I seem to be eating crow a lot in my recent reviews, usually as I read what I said at the end of the last one and realize that no, it went counter to all my expectations. And last time I said that I felt that White’s encounter with D would not likely change her all that much, and boy howdy was I wrong. It’s not perfect, and only with alone with the Demon Lord is she starting to be “herself”, but the days of “White Can’t Communicate” are coming to an end, as she now… talks in sentences! Expresses emotions! Thanks people! I’ve gotten used to her main character trait being the dissonance between her chatty inner monologue and her deadpan outside self that I was not expecting that she would finally bridge the gap. A lot of this is likely due to D, and the big revelation from last time of who her real self is.

The Demon Lord gets a lot accomplished in this book, firstly by taking out a major rebellion against her (which White actually gave her all the details on), then by meeting with the pontiff and making a deal with save Miss Oka and a group of elves that were part of the rebellion (at White’s request) in return for promising to kill off all the Elves at a later date (we do see some of this in earlier books). The Demon Lord also finally hears about what’s really happening with this world,. again thanks to White, but does not hear how much sacrifice and deaths it will take to fix things, again because White does not tell her. The Power Behind The Throne has never felt more appropriate, even as everyone continues to attribute this to the Demon Lord being just that brilliant. Oh, yes, and White can now actually cause physical pain to Ariel as well, though this is passed off as a gag.

I will admit that I do appreciate the gags, because let’s face it, this series has gotten about as dark as Overlord, which I dropped for being too dark. So White being all embarrassed is funny, as is most everything about Sophia being a massive spoiled brat. And then there’s D, a totally awful God, who is still finding the idea that the new God of this world is really a tiny spider that she swapped roles with so as to get away from being found after being reincarnated. The other reason the series is still good to read is the occasional heartwarming moment. I liked White trying to save Ms. Oka, and the flashback back to the classroom where we see why: Ms. Oka stopped the class killing the spider, and hence White herself, before they all got exploded. I also liked the ending with White taking Ariel to meet the legendary Sariel, and we see how she’s suffering for the entire world. It gives “saving the world” a face.

Still, there’s no denying this series is pretty damn dark – lots of slaughter in this book as well. That said, the best thing about this volume is White really starting to come into her own and take over as THE protagonist once more.

Girls Kingdom, Vol. 1

Leave a reply

By Nayo and Shio Sakura. Released in Japan by GL Bunko. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Philip Reuben.

Despite the fact that this is a review of Vol. 1 of a fairly new light novel series, the one thing I took away from it most was nostalgia. This book is drenched in Maria-sama Ga Miteru and Strawberry Panic, two series from the 00s that defined a generation of yuri, for better and worse. (In that order – Maria-sama for Better, Strawberry Panic for worse.) I think the author is well aware of what the audience wants here, and is quite happy to give it to them with the maximum amount of ridiculousness. There may be heartwarming moments and genuine yuri in future volumes, though I’m skeptical. What we get here, though, is one girl’s entry into a magical kingdom, one where she ends up having the Golden Ticket – almost literally – that puts her among the elite. And we get another girl, at the pinnacle of that elite, and her desire to try to have as little to do with it as possible. They need each other. They make a great pair.

Misaki is a young girl starting her first day at a new school. She runs out of her house screaming she’s going to be late (no toast, sadly), but ends up being VERY late, as the school is ridiculously huge. So late she jumps the gate – an expellable offense – but it’s OK, as Himeko is standing there, and is highly amused at the fact that a) Misaki jumped the gate at ALL, and b) Misaki seems to know NOTHING about the school that she’s starting in today. So she gets Misaki to agree to be her maid, in exchange for getting her out of being expelled. Misaki is rather baffled by this, then finds out why this school that she signed up for but knew nothing about is free: the half of the class she’s in are all training to be maids, so they may serve the OTHER half of the class. Which has Himeko, who is daughter of the Chairman of the Board.

As you can see, this premise is bananas, for many, many reasons. Misaki’s ignorance of EVERYTHING about her new school is hilarious. A school for maids-in-training and their rich young mistresses is so egregiously classist that your jaw will drop. Misaki’s roommate Kirara, who in any other series like this would be the protagonist, does things that made me physically recoil from my phone as I was reading the book. There are identical twins – with the same first name – who appear to be on the maid side for shits and giggles, which is fine as that’s how they live everything else in their life. Himeko is the perfect rich young girl, right down to living like an absolute slob and not giving a rat’s ass what anyone thinks of her. The book is basically a series of train wrecks set to prose.

That said, I had a grin on my face reading it. If you can put up with its silliness, it’s fun. If you ever saw or read Strawberry Panic, it’s required reading.