Category Archives: reviews

Plunderer, Vol. 1

By Suu Minazuki. Released in Japan by Kadokawa Shoten, serialization ongoing in the magazine Shonen Ace. Released in North America by Yen Press. Translated by Ko Ransom.

Yes, yes, OK, I should have known better. Sometimes I preorder new series without paying much attention to what’s actually going on. Like, for example, the fact that this is written by Suu Minazuki, creator of Gou-dere Sora Nagihara, which I wasn’t fond of; Judas, licensed digitally by Viz but looking to be along the same lines; and Heaven’s Lost Property, whose length is probably the only reason it too was not brought over here. The author has a reputation for fanservice, let’s put it that way. Now he’s turning his attention to fantasy with this series, which features a plot which made so little sense that I had to go back and read the explanation again. It also gets pretty dark, to the point where I wonder if the editor said “can you add some blatant panty shots to cheer the reader up?” and the artist smiled and gave a thumbs up. That said… it’s written for an audience of teenage boys, and boy, does it know that market.

We start off with Hina, a young girl (she seems to fall into that “am I eight years old or sixteen?” type) who is searching for the Fabled Ace, a war hero who may or may not be a legend. Instead she finds a perverted guy who wears a mask, whose goal is to look up her skirt, and a nice bartender woman, whose goal is to explain why everyone has number tattooed on them. Each number is a thing that a person can achieve – the bartender has a number that’s the times her food has been called good, while Hina’s is apparently the miles she’s walked – and when that number hits zero, the person is sucked up by black tentacle things and sent to “The Abyss”. The achievement can be ANYTHING, which makes it simply confusing. Moreover, Hina is naive and trusts too easily. Fortunately for her, she has an ally, sort of. Unfortunately, it’s the pervert in a mask.

This series runs on fanservice to a large degree – when Hina has to disappear from the plot for a bit, we are introduced to a young sergeant major in the military who fills much the same position – and I absolutely do not recommend it to anyone whose tolerance for panty shots is low. That said, what about the rest of it? Well, I’ve made my opinion of the “count” thing clear, I think it’s overly confusing and a plot convenience. The actual plot is following Hina and Licht (the guy in the mask) as they try to avoid everyone going after her as she has a “ballot”, which is another macguffin that means essentially “whoever holds this has power”. The overall tone of the manga suggests it’s going to be fairly grim, and I suspect a few of the cast are not going to survive. That said, this is written by a creator who’s been around for several years, so the composition is fine, and the fights are exciting enough.

Basically, this is a volume that hits its demographic, but ONLY its demographic. If you’re a teenage boy, you’ll love this. All others should read something else.

True Tenchi Muyo!: Washu

By Yousuke Kuroda and Masaki Kajishima. Released in Japan as “Shin Tenchi Muyo! Ryo-o-ki” by Kadokawa Shoten. Released in North America by Seven Seas. Translated by Lillian Olsen. Adapted by AstroNerdBoy.

The subject of this book may come as a surprise, given that the first two books in this series focused, not on Ayeka and Ryoko, but on Ayeka’s father and Tenchi’s grandfather. But yes, the third book is out, and finally we have one that gives us backstory on one of the main cast. The prologue to this story takes place after the Tenchi OAV episode where they all have to take care of the baby, and expands on Washu’s past that came out in that episode, which was that she’d had a husband and child, but they were immediately taken from her. As such, the bulk of the book goes back in time – way back – and shows us Washu as a young woman, leaving her adopted home planet and going to the Imperial Academy’s Department of Philosophy… at the age of eighteen, smashing all records. There she meets a familiar young man…

First of all, it’s simply odd to have most of the book dealing with a Washu that isn’t 20,000 years old (cryofreezing notwithstanding). Washu here is young and idealistic, though she’s already starting to work on her snarky side. This is helped along by her sempai at the academy, Naja, who seems to be another one of those characters that all Tenchi fans should know about because they read the ancillary material. Naja basically fulfills the function of Airi in the last book, only without the romance (mostly: there is a hint that Naja’s moaning about boyfriends is a front for something else, but it never goes anywhere and also plays into uncomfortable “watch out for the predatory lesbian” territory once or twice). No, the romance comes from a young man who has a knack of walking in on Washu even when she’s in libraries with very tight security. They fall in love quickly, and have a child, but he has a Secret Past (a theme in all these books), and their love is quickly shattered.

It is, to me at least, a bit disconcerting that Washu’s husband is basically a Rule 63 Mihoshi. It’s a bit less surprising for those who’ve seen the other OAVs and know that Mihoshi’s family and ancestors all look almost exactly the same, but disconcerting nonetheless. The best part of the book is simply watching Washu have to deal with being a big fish in a very big pond – everyone wants to treat her like a VIP, and she hates that. It’s also amusing to see Dr. Clay, the pathetic villain in the 2nd Tenchi OAV series, as a pathetic younger villain in these books – well, villain is the wrong word. Jerk? The best part of the book may be Washu’s covert meeting with her husband’s new wife, which leads to a jaw-dropping bit that the narrative, thankfully (if sadly), did not take. Very well done.

There were supposed to be three more books after this one. I believe the fourth was about Mihoshi’s family, and may have finally given us the backstory to her that only the OAVs really had (it was hinted she was a crack, serious police officer till something broke her). Alas, it’s been twenty years, so I think this is all we get. Still, it’s a wonderful nostalgia trip for Tenchi fans.

Defeating the Demon Lord’s a Cinch (If You’ve Got a Ringer), Vol. 3

By Tsukikage and bob. Released in Japan as “Darenidemo Dekiru Kage kara Tasukeru Maou Toubatsu” by Famitsu Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Caleb DeMarais.

It’s becoming clear that these books live or die based on the “guest” characters. The last book had a poor orphan girl who was so fed up by the antics of Ares and Amelia that she willingly went along with the villain at the end. But she was somewhat grounded, and this made everything easier to take. This time around we have Stephenne, whose joke is that everyone assumes her to be faking her “dojikko” personality because no one could truly be that dumb and unaware, but nope, what you see seems to be what you get. If anything, Stephenne helps to highlight one of the points of the book. Everyone is appalled at her basic personality, especially because she’s a super high level and can crush most things. Why would you not have her in the party? Well, because she’s like that. Yes, I just describes Ares. Replace “dojikko” with “asshole” and they’re the same character. No wonder his boss gets headaches just talking to him. It’s like watching Maxwell Smart and the Chief.

The premise is much the same as last time – our hero party has entered a new place, but they need to level up and get stronger, so Ares and company tail them and try to facilitate things. Stephenne is supposed to help on both sides, but she’s such a walking disaster that no one wants anything to do with her. In the meantime, Golem Valley, where this book takes place, seems to be distressingly free of dangerous golems. Oh, there’s enough so that the hero can defeat them, but where are the super strong ones? As Ares investigates, he finds that the demon lord has also sent a party to Golem Valley. A confrontation is needed, and Ares has to do the only thing he knows how to do really well: piss everyone off.

Last time I found Ares slightly less obnoxious and awful, but that’s changed once more – he’s really terrible in this book, and you absolutely can see why most sensible people want nothing to do with him. Amelia, who is in love with him, isn’t much better, as for God’s sake, WHY? Seeing her jealousy at Stephenne hanging out with Ares and her increasingly unsubtle hints just makes me wince. They’re helped by a half-giant turned priest, who’s the nicest, most relatable character in the book and ends it by now speaking to Ares. Meanwhile, the hero party are suffering from now being good enough to defeat most low-level threats. All the major flaws from the first book have been explained or are about to be fixed. Unfortunately, that makes them all rather dull, with most of the interest, again, coming from Stephenne interacting with the party and being herself.

I’m not sure how much we’re supposed to sympathize with Stephenne here – the author doesn’t seem to like her much either, and the ending where her spirit familiar abandons her seems to be mean. But then the book runs on mean, because Ares is its star. It’s well-written and I like the plot beats, but man, you grit your teeth reading it. The fourth volume seems to be the last so far in Japan – perhaps Japanese readers feel the same? (EDIT: No, it’s apparently that the author is working on more than one series. It is still ongoing.)