Category Archives: reviews

Caterpillar Girl and Bad Texter Boy

Leave a reply

By Sanzo. Released in Japan as “Imomushi Shoujo to Komyushou Danshi” by Kadokawa Shoten, serialized in the magazine Gene Pixiv. Released in North America by Yen Press. Translated by Alexandra McCullough-Garcia.

I’m not sure what I was expecting going into reading Caterpillar Girl and Bad Texter Boy. I knew the basic premise, but that’s about it. I think I expected a cute, slice-of-life thing with heartwarming moments. I also expected by the end of the book everything would be back to normal. Neither of those things happen, and in fact the book goes to a lot of dark places that I wasn’t expecting. That makes it a richer experience, though, and even as I was reading along and going “holy crap”, I was appreciating what the author was doing, peeling apart the backstory of a hero that I honestly didn’t like at all at the start, and making you think twice about the love on his childhood friend, which goes from zero to obsession in the flashbacks. And then there’s the God who puts all this in motion. The book has a lot of balls in the air, but juggles them very well.

The book wastes no time getting into its basic premise. Suzume is pretty, accomplished, and popular. She is childhood friends with Akane, who is introverted, somewhat plain, and has a massive case of self-hatred. So when she confesses to him, his response is variations on “there’s no way someone like you could go for someone like me”. After which she promptly disappears… and then shows up in front of him as a giant human-sized caterpillar. No, this isn’t metaphorical this time around. She made a wish to a shrine god that she could be an ugly creature so that he wouldn’t have to worry about her being pretty and popular. The trouble is that she REALLY didn’t think this through, and can’t really grasp anything, food tastes bad, and she now feels totally useless. As for Akane, he still hates himself, but now he feels guilty. What’s more, turns out one of Suzume’s friends at school is in fact the God she was praying to… and she hates Akane.

The second half of this book, right about where we start to get the perspective of Ouga, the classmate and God mentioned above, ends up being so riveting that I don’t actually want to spoil it. Which, for those readers who know that I casually spoil absolutely everything, is really saying something. Seeing Akane’s backstory made me realize that he’s not just some whiny loser protagonist but has real built-up issues. We also see that Suzume’s love is incredibly unhealthy, both in her past as a human and in her present as a caterpillar, and as we head towards the ending (the book is complete in one volume) we realize that this is not one of those “happily ever after” books so much as “ever after”. There are no easy answers when you love someone so much you transform into a caterpillar for them.

This isn’t an easy read – the three leads all have difficult personalities that we have to deal with, and I think there are some readers who might have preferred the cutesy heartwarming story I thought we were getting going in. But I’m very happy I read this, as the emotional heft of it was fantastic.
Not your typical “monster girl” manga.

Outbreak Company, Vol. 4

Leave a reply

By Ichiro Sakaki and Yuugen. Released in Japan by Kodansha. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Kevin Steinbach.

This is quite a short volume of Outbreak Company, and as such it doesn’t really do a heck of a lot to advance the forward plot. Its main thrust can be divided into three: 1) Due to the soccer game from last book being filmed and then leaked onto Youtube, Shinichi and company have to figure out how to cover up something that’s already gone viral; 2) Petralka is starting to burn out a bit, and her advisors aren’t really sure how to deal with a teenage empress; and 3) the author has realized that Minori hasn’t really had much of a backstory, and thus has Shinichi actually notice she’s uncomfortable when he calls her feminine and asks her about her past and background. In the afterword, the author says this was supposed to be Minori’s book but Petralka sort of shoved herself in; I think that may have been a good idea, as while Minori’s past is suitably sad, it doesn’t really tie into anything else. It’s there just for development.

Minori doesn’t even get the cover (she was the logical choice), as instead we have Magical Girl Petralka. Shinichi’s idea to stop the Youtube rumors is to put out a few more video clips that make it clear that this is a movie, and that it’s just CGI people saw. This dovetails nicely with Petralka needing a bit of distraction from the heavy weight of power, and so she ends up being the star. Unfortunately, as you’d expect from a girl who’s done nothing but rule the country or be prepared to rule the country, Petralka decides she likes life on the other side a bit TOO much, and needs to be smacked back with some harsh reality. These are probably the best scenes in the book, and show off the main reason why Outbreak Company is still a good read – Shinichi is very good at reading people, and figuring out what they need.

As for Minori, despite telling Shinichi about her past, and saying that she understands why the other girls have all fallen for him, there’s no indication that she has done the same, which is fine with me. She gre up as the Heir to the Dojo, but as iwth a lot of Heirs to the Dojo who are female, her dad wanted a boy and she can’t help but always be inadequate. Puberty also didn’t help, which is probably why Shinichi’s obsession wi8th her large breasts is not all that welcome (though I would not expect it to end either – this is still a Japanese light novel). That said, she gets to save the day when a large dragon attacks the film site (which is the one part of the book hinting at future plotlines, as the dragon seems to have been mind controlled by another nation), and hopefully she’ll feel more comfortable with herself as the series goes on.

This wasn’t the best volume of Outbreak Company, and it felt more like filling time than anything else. But there were still lots of good scenes and funny character bits, and it’s enough to tide us over till the next book, which I hope is more plot-heavy.

Little Witch Academia, Vol. 1

Leave a reply

By Trigger, Yoh Yoshinari and Keisuke Sato. Released in Japan by Kadokawa Shoten, serialization ongoing in the magazine Shonen Ace. Released in North America by JY. Translated by Taylor Engel.

Despite this being another franchise where I’ve never actually seen the anime, I knew quite a bit about it to begin with. It was a Kickstarter series that blew up into a full-fledged TV anime, it’s been described as “Harry Potter if they were all girls”, and Akko/Diana is the preferred ship, I am told. Other than that, I was ready to be charmed by this manga, which is coming out here under Yen’s “JY” line, so is definitely being marketed to younger readers. Which I can see, as kids will love this. It’s a good title for adults as well, though, and Akko makes a fun heroine – fallible and sloppy, but also filled with a love of life that puts a smile on your face. It also helps that she’s surrounded by a few snarkers to help take the sugary edge off.

The manga does assume to a certain degree that you’re already familiar with its source, but for the neophyte, there is an introductory chapter. Akko is a wannabe witch who’s bad at flying, trying to make her way to the Witchcraft Academy, rather unusual for a Japanese student. Through a series of misadventures, she meets two other students – the glasses-wearing, earnest Lotte and the sarcastic, droopy-eyed Sucy – and she ends up at the Academy, ready to follow in the footsteps of her idol Chariot. The rest of the book shows various Academy events, as we see that Akko is not the best student in the world, but makes up for it with lots of energy, drive and GUTS! In other words, despite being all girls, this is a perfect series to run in Shonen Ace, and it wouldn’t be too out of place in Jump either.

For fans of Diana, she’s not as prevalent in this first manga as I was expecting, but there’s enough of her here to see why fans really like to pair off the two of them – they’re very Usagi and Rei. I can also see the Harry Potter comparison, mostly as the three main characters map somewhat to Harry, Hermione and Ron, though Harry was never quite this hyperactive, and Quidditch is replaced by volleyball – where they aren’t supposed to use magic, but do anyway. If there’s a fault with the manga, it’s that it does feel something like a side story to the main anime – there’s no sense that this is going in its own direction, but filling in some gaps that the main story, which was animated, left out. That said, there are hints that we’re going to be getting a bit deeper, such as the cliffhanger ending to this volume.

If you like the anime, or have kids who did, I can’t see why you wouldn’t pick this up. As for me, it makes me want to try the anime to see what I’m missing.