Category Archives: reviews

The Countess Is a Coward No More! This Reincarnated Witch Just Wants a Break, Vol. 2

Leave a reply

By Ageha Sakura and TCB. Released in Japan as “Tensei Saki ga Kiyowa Sugiru Hakushaku Fujin datta” by Overlap Novels f. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Bérénice Vourdon.

This is not an isekai title, and it’s not QUITE a reincarnation title, even though it features that, mostly as they’re not reincarnated from Japan. Everyone in this fantasy world seems to have been born in it at some point. But it is one of those titles, like Reborn to Master the Blade or A Tale of the Secret Saint, where our protagonist was an incredibly powerful and influential person in the past, and now that they’ve reincarnated into the future, they find that their past is not so easy to get rid of. This is more literally true for Lam than others in this genre, as not only was she forcibly reincarnated via a spell, but all of her disciples are there as well. And unfortunately, this gets to one of the parts of the title that I wish weren’t the case… all of her disciples are, to one degree or another, yanderes. Fortunately, she has minimal interest in anyone but Char… who gets SLIGHTLY more than minimal.

Things start off fairly normally, as Lam decides she wants to attend a tea party for nobility, which goes about as well as you’d expect, given that she’s still assumed to be an introverted coward by those who haven’t met her new self. After that, though, we get the real plot, as Lam is asked to go to the country of Levres, whose prince wants to meet her. Naturally, Char comes along, and they take Canon as well. It turns out that the prince is the reincarnation of her second disciple, Glacial, who was reincarnated properly with his memories from the start, unlike Lam’s broken reincarnation. Now Prince Fleche, he wants Lam to marry him and live with him forever – much to Char’s displeasure. Unfortunately, the hatred of mages has also followed them to this kingdom, helped along by the Church.

This series has a very big problem for me, which is not a deal breaker so far but the ice is getting thinner. The problem is that while I like the basic situation, I usually want to sympathize with… anyone. Lam is fairly emotionally stunted, quick to deal with “insects” when she’s annoyed, and, while she’s not aromantic per se, she might as well be given her inability to get anyone’s point. The men in her life are all various shades of obsessed with/in love with her, and Char is possibly the only one who actually cares about what SHE thinks about this… and the implication is that if he finds out she was actually Aurora, he won’t care about her own feelings either. The bad guys are also mostly immature brats with far too much power and a tendency to not care about anyone or anything. And given they all have magic, even the people trying to prejudice the world against magic, that’s not a good thing. You want to smack them.

This ends with a cliffhanger, so we’ll see how all these men decide to resolve who gets to marry and have sex with a woman who really doesn’t want to be married to anyone but Char, and who still tends to blush and have a look of horror if sex is mentioned. I’ll keep going, but buyer beware.

Did You Think My Yuri Was Just for Show?

Leave a reply

By Neru Asakura and Minori Chigusa. Released in Japan as “Watashi no Yuri mo, Eigyou da to Omotta?” by Dengeki Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Janny McKeon.

I wasn’t really sure what this was going to be when I first saw it. The author hasn’t had other titles licensed for the West (though they apparently wrote another, “spicier” yuri title previously). It’s also a one-shot. That said, I ended up enjoying it a lot more than I thought I would, although not necessarily for the yuri aspect of it. It’s an excellent look at the voice acting industry and how it can be very boom or bust at any time, told to us through the viewpoint of one of its bigger stars (though she would deny that). It also gets into the terror of idol fandom, both “trying to start a scandal for clicks” fandom and also what you do when you’re confronted with your celebrity crush in real life and you want to keep that sort of thing separate. Mostly, though, I enjoyed this because of its main character, Suzune, who is fantastic.

Suzune is, for once in this sort of series, NOT an up-and-coming wannabe voice actress. Instead, our narrator is well-established in the industry, not a top star but getting several roles a season, with usually one or two major titles. She’s also ‘yuri for real’ (gay and lesbian are not used, as the novel leans very deliberately into the ‘yuri’ label), something she’s hiding from most people except her friend at work who is the same. That said, Suzune hasn’t really experienced actual love per se. Sure, she’s a massive fan of Karin Shotsuki, the former leader of idol group DIAGONAL who mysteriously retired a few months ago. But being an ‘oshi’ for an idol is not the same thing as love, right? Then, of course, she’s introduced to the new kid on the block at the agency the next day… the same Karin.

Suzune is a type I always like, which is modest and realistic, a bit self-deprecating, but not overly so, and VERY good at what she does. Her professionalism throughout (well, mostly, I’ll get to it) was fantastic, and I even appreciated the scenes she had with the evil villain washed-up voice actress, which she was handling well enough but which Karin, out of necessity, had to take over. Speaking of Karin, she’s fine, and I liked her, but a bit less. I do think that Suzune was missing some very obvious signs that Karin was massively in love with her from the start, but given that Suzune was asking what love really is anyway, that can be expected. The one weak part of the book is the final scene, which not only feels very unrealistic (both in terms of what Suzune does, and the lack of consequences), but also feels abrupt as heck, as if the author was told to stop as they had a page limit.

Still, that’s 90% of a really great book. And it’s a one-shot, so you’re not investing much. For fans of voice actors and fans of yuri.

Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? Minor Myths and Legends, Vol. 1

Leave a reply

By Fujino Omori and nilitsu. Released in Japan as “Dungeon ni Deai o Motomeru no wa Machigatte Iru Darou ka? Shohenshu” by GA Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Jake Humphrey.

Oh goody, another short story collection, the first of two that have been given fancier names to disguise the fact that this is a collection of extra stories mostly written for bookstore exclusives, which means by definition that all of them, with one or two exceptions, not only cannot impact the ongoing narrative but cannot impact any of the character arcs. That said, I am always grateful that we get these anyway, as it’s nice to see the little content that Japanese readers got when they bought the volume at Toranoana, Animate, or Gamers. What’s more, fans of the harem aspect of this series, which usually takes a backseat in the main series to the ongoing “series of fights to the death” plot, will be eating well here. Everyone loves Bell and knows it (except Aiz), and Bell is clueless to everyone’s love but loves Aiz (who is clueless towards him). It’s in the title of the franchise!

Trying to summarize all of these would be impossible – most of them only run two pages or so. They take place over the course of Vol. 1-18 of the main series. Some of the ones that are longer than two pages include Eina and Bell’s first meeting, Hestia trying to be Bell’s supporter in the dungeon, a story taking place right after Bell first starts to become famous and shows off his growth as the smith who made his first knife asks if he can put it in his “hall of fame” section, after Vol. 6, Hestia tries another ball to try to dance with Bell, but it proves very difficult; Fels watches over Hestia Familia during the Xenos arc, and keeps a diary of what they are seeing – which quickly turns into a confessional of a sort, Cassandra makes another effort to get people to believe her right before the disaster that sends Bell and Lyu to the deep levels, Lyu and Bell are forced to drink slimes to survive in the dungeon, and three more that I’ll talk about below.

The three stories that work best here are the ones that actually *are* able to do something with character development. They all take place during the “Freya” arc of the series. Bell is going through enforced date training so he can go out with Syr, and as part of it rescues an Elf in Hermes Familia and tries to be suave as he was taught. It works far, far too well. In the second, we get the POV of Horn during the time when Bell is staying with Freya Familia and she’s manipulating everyone’s memories, which shows both Freya’s guilt and angst over her lot in love as well as her massive tsundere nature over Bell; and in the final, funniest story, Laurier does her own character poll of everyone in Orario, and runs into Horn, who is at loose ends after Freya’s fall. The cat fight they both get into, with Laurier praising Bell so much it makes you sick, and Horn tearing him down as much as possible, is simply fantastic.

That said, overall.. this is a short story collection. For fans only. Join us soon for Vol. 2, which has all the store giveaway stories for Sword Oratoria.