By Iota Aiue and Tsukasa Kuga. Released in Japan as “Shokeisareta Akujo wa, Taikoku de Kouhi no Za wo Tsukamu” by DRE Novels. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Mac B. Gill.

There was a lot of this that I liked, but the middle part made me want to start flicking throughn it, and it’s mostly due to the big villain. Look, as evil beyond evil villains go, this guy is pretty good at avoiding the absolute worst. He doesn’t have a bowl haircut or an arrogant laugh. He’s not trying to sexually assault any of our cast. For light novel standards, he’s subtle. Likewise, his punishment is very apropos for this kinda on the cynical end of the spectrum world. But man, he’s a bummer. Whipping his daughter, murdering thousands with poison dresses and flowers, also providing the poison used to kill our main villainess, drove a family to suicide and enslavement… there’s a very definite reason why the emperor is giving Westalia a chance, even though it looks like he’s not. There’s a very real chance that if Elizabeth wins the competition, the country is doomed. Bit of a bummer, honestly.

Now that Westalia and Elizabeth have tied in the Empress competition, there has to be a run off. The Emperor decides that the two of them will gather artificial flowers. They get a budget and a warehouse, which they have to fill with them. Given Elizabeth’s family is in textiles, this is obviously very biased towards her, but Westalia suspects the Emperor has a bigger reason for doing this – he wants the Reyn family’s secrets uncovered and to see them destroyed – without Tiberio, Elizabeth’s father and head of the family, getting out of it and pinning it on someone else, as he’s done before. What’s worse, Elizabeth seems to be falling ill with symptoms that seem very similar to poisoning, and Paige recognizes Tiberio as the man who destroyed her family and sold her into slavery. Westalia is really, really starting this event in a hole.

There are, of course, reasons I did enjoy this book. Every time Westalia loses her temper and gets mad is not only kind of scary but actually comedy gold, especially when she gets the official scribe to implicate the villain but fails to realize that the scribe will also be describing her own acts as well. More importantly, though, this is a book about people who have been abandoned and broken by loved ones learning how to reach out and accept help. Westalia is trying to do things on her own, and it doesn’t work, she needs to work with and trust everyone, even after dying once. Paige has to get past her rage and despair about the death of her parents and learn how to work trough this positively. And Elizabeth has to realize that fighting back against her father is better than ruling as a puppet while she slowly dies. (That last one is harder than it seems, defying your abuser requires a lot of gumption.)

Fortunately, everyone lives happily ever after and recovers from being poisoned, except that one guy. And so the series is over, and it’s a good end. That said, only get this if you get all the villainess books.

By Iota Aiue and Tsukasa Kuga. Released in Japan as “Shokeisareta Akujo wa, Taikoku de Kouhi no Za wo Tsukamu” by DRE Novels. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Mac B. Gill.

I would not be reviewing 80 billion of these villainess books if I was not a big fan of the genre. As such, I can usually forgive it if it’s a bit on the nose. There are a lot fewer surprises in this first book than is perhaps required, although you might call the end of the book a surprise, as I sense that making this a series rather than a standalone book was a last-minute decision borne out by the rushed non-ending. It does, however, have a terrific romantic couple as our leads. The villainess is honorable, noble, tricky, stubborn, etc. in equal measure. The prince (technically that is a spoiler, but come on, it’s revealed almost immediately and is not a surprise even then) is handsome, self-assured without being smug, and they realistically realize the truth about each other very fast. Also, there’s a handsome woman knight, who is such a great character I will ignore our heroine buying her as a slave (it’s fixed almost immediately).

We open with Westalia, our heroine, being executed after being framed for an attempted murder by her supposed best friend. (I did say this was a typical villainess book.) But it’s OK. She’s taken an antidote, and rises from the dead when her grave is being robbed. Fleeing across borders, she ends up in the Archadies Empire, where the Empress is chosen by a country-wide search. Though, given the literacy rate is pretty low, the finalists do tend to be rich nobles. Westalia came here on purpose. After spending her life trying to learn to be a good queen only to be betrayed, she’ll be damned if she’s going to thrown away trying to help people and do good. So she’s going to become Empress by hook or by crook. Fortunately, the only real competition she has seems very familiar, as if every villainess needs an idiot heroine…

I talked about being a fan of villainess stories, which means I’ve met my share of bratty younger sisters, evil heroines, etc. We get two varieties for the price of one here. Both are presented as “mostly sort of evil”, which is to say they’re evil until the point where the author allows them a bit of depth. Lily has always hated Westalia, and was too busy pretending to be her best friend to realize that her dilemma of being married off to a creepy middle-aged man might have been something solvable with Westalia’s help. (She’s merely disgraced, so we may see her again.) Meanwhile, Elizabeth is using her money and connections to buy the contest, so is very upset when that still isn’t enough. She seems to at least have a bit of self-awareness. She’s definitely coming back, because they rewrote the cliffhanger to assure it.

If you are a villainess fan, this is really good. If you can take or leave it, you probably won’t like it. I’ll definitely read more, though I suspect it might have been better as a one-shot.