By Takibi Amamori and Imigimuru. Released in Japan as “Make Heroine ga Ōsugiru!” by Gagaga Bunko. Released in North America by Airship. Translated by Matthew Jackson. Adapted by Hayame.
Urgh. Not only is this a collection of microstories, but the volume after this is 8.5, meaning it will also have short stories. At least that one looks to see original stories designed to “bridge the gap” between 8 and 9. This one is 100% “I wrote this 2-page story for the folks who buy the book at Bookstore X”. There’s nothing wrong with any of them. They’re funny, occasionally cringey, Anna eats a lot… they’re exactly what you’d want in a Losing Heroines book. But there’s no actual plot or characterization. You cannot develop characters in a bookstore-only exclusive 2-oage short story. And I have over 300 words to go. To be honest, I was actually impressed at how dedicated the author was to shilling for the bookstores. Some of them are basically advertisements. As are the short stories commissioned by a local zoo, which work in the zoo’s exhibits. As an added bonus, most of these being for bookstores means that we get more of Nukumizu’s ridiculous light novel titles, most of which are romcoms. Of course.
The cover shows that, unlike most short story books, which usually are “SS” in Japan, this one is “SSS”. I’m not sure if that’s because of the series’ three supposed heroines or what. The fact that it’s a short story collection also means we get a repeat cover star for the first time, as Anna is back, making a heart with both hands… that’s off kilter to show that her heart is broken. I am not going to bother to break down each microstory here, but they are all basically stories sold as extras for the first six volumes, plus two stories written for Nonhoi Park, a 100-acre botanical park with a zoo. They all focus on the main heroines, as well as Kaju, with other girls occasionally getting a look in. I’d say they’re about 80% Nukumizu POV, with a few showing off the girls by themselves. Anna eats a lot in them.
Actually, that does lead me to what was my favorite story in the collection. A larger than usual short story written fro Bookwalker has Nukumizu alone at home when Anna drops by, as her phone has run out of charge and she needs to borrow his outlet. This works out nicely, as it’s her birthday, and this is the perfect time to give her a present that, frankly, was far more expensive than I was expecting from someone like Nukumizu. The present is both hilarious, because it’s Anna, but also really heartwarming and sweet. He really gets her. As for my least favorite stories, I’m sorry, but Kaju’s obsession with her brother is never going to land for me, and so her stories, which were all variations on that theme, were not my bag. Well, OK, I was mildly amused at the one where she manipulates a competition to get a photo of them taken as bride and groom… one which will be used as advertisements all over the town. God, girl, please find someone else.
What about Gondou, for example? Who only appeared here briefly, but is on the cover of the next book, 8.5. Yeah, not happening, this series already has its yuri teaser. In any case, Losing Heroines fans will enjoy this, mostly as they don’t have to review it.
