By Kazuma Ogiwara and CARIMARICA. Released in Japan as “Isekai Toushou no Maken Seisaku Gurashi” by Kadokawa Books. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Ryan Burris.

While there are still bouts of humor in this series, it has not escaped my attention that each volume seems to be darker than the last, and this one was particularly dark. Dead adventurers, dead women and children, bandits everywhere, lots of justified hatred of nobles, and the realization that the city that our heroes live in really does have a lot of issues, and they’re desperately trying to force it to become a place that people might actually want to go. Which, frankly, it isn’t at the moment. The cast is also pretty static – we’ve met potential new characters, and one of them even returns in this book, but for the most part once we get to know them they leave the city. Hell, even Claudia threatens to take Lutz and go somewhere more welcoming. Though I suspect a lot of that is that she’s tired of Lutz throwing himself into deadly situations.

We open on a party of adventurers running from a zombie, and when one of them trips, the others… run away. She’s saved by Lutz, who happened to be in the dungeon and is also the main character, but she can’t rejoin that party. Fortunately, she finds another party… and then the exact same thing happens, only she is the one who runs while her new party are killed by a flame demon. She’s a mess. This flame demon has also massacred a village of carpenters Lutz worked with, and their village leader, Kevin, wants revenge. He’s a mess. And then there’s Djoser, head of the knights, such as they are, who is dealing with a bout of self-hatred, not at all helped by coming across bandits butchering everyone except an old merchant. He’s a mess. As for Lutz? He’s fine.

Well, OK, he’s not ALL fine. His beloved axe gets destroyed, but this allows him to make an even better katana with the remains. His main worry is that he keeps worrying Claudia, who loves Lutz a lot and very much does not want to keep being the good wifey who waits for her man to come home and worries he never will. She gets only one really good scene here, but it’s a pip, as she points out exactly how valuable she and Lutz are to the city and how much they’re starting to rely on him magically solving all their problems. We’re starting to see the Count trying to do something about it – creating a knight unit that not made of of noble rapists will help, though notably, even then they have to create a SECOND knight unit and leave the dissolute first one, as they all have connections. Better roads would help, but the bandit problem is not going away, and since the bandits just seems to be “those damn nobles”, it may take a more complicated fix than any of our leads can do. There’s good worldbuilding here, but the world is hard.

This remains one of my favorite new light novel titles, but it can be very grim. There are no easy solutions.

By Kazuma Ogiwara and CARIMARICA. Released in Japan as “Isekai Toushou no Maken Seisaku Gurashi” by Kadokawa Books. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Ryan Burris.

This remains a series written almost entirely for teenage boys, but it’s worth noting that this isn’t just one aspect of things teenage boys like. Obviously there’s the stuff about the swords, because teen boys love swords, and fantasy authors love treating the swords like they’re women, which this book absolutely does. It’s also written for teen boys in terms of the sexuality – Lutz and Claudia remain very sexually active, and a princess of another country’s city/tribe is mostly described by her large breasts. But there’s something else teenage boys like, and that’s grimdark, and this series has that as well. It never quite spills over into actual tragedy, but there’s a lot of bleak, depressing stuff in this series, ranging from the start with Claudia being saved from a fate worse than death (more on that later), to a clan leader who has let the love of a sword turn him evil, to a vengeful knight seeking to atone for past sins by killing his fellow sinners. It’s not fluffy.

This story essentially consists of two parts. In the first, Lutz, Claudia, and Ricardo head to the federation to see what’s going on there after the death of their king. Turns out things aren’t great. They meet up with Gwynn, the guy who asked Lutz to create a katana he could give painless death with, and together they head to a wretchedly poor city where the chief seems to really, really hate them. He has a daughter who’s far more sensible, but he also has a bewitching katana that has killed three of her brothers when they challenged dear old dad. Maybe an unbewitching katana from Lutz can help. When they return home, they find that there’s a masked avenger going around killing the lazy knights, and while Lutz and especially Claudia have no love lost for those guys, Lutz decides to investigate just in case this turns out to be the fault of one of his katanas, like almost everything else in this series.

There is some humor in this, of course. The darkness of the village chief and his bewitching sword is offset by the adorableness of the first love between Gwynn and Melty. There’s another subplot about Ricardo asking for a second katana to be used with Tsubaki as a dual wield, and it’s up to Lutz to show Ricardo that dual wielding is something mostly done by fictional heroes for good reason. But we see slavery here, and a village whose people are starving to death just because its chief wants a second priceless katana to go with his first. There’s also the entire plot with Donaldo, who worships Lutz for all the wrong reasons. Lutz has to secretly meet with Donaldo to resolve this, because much as Claudia likes to pretend that she’s over the terror of what the knights did to her in the first book, she’s really not, and he knows that he needs to handle this away from her. The darkness of this world leaks in whether you want it to or not, and it’s impossible to get rid of.

It will be interesting to see where this series goes next – especially given we’re now seeing Enchanted Weapons by people other than Lutz. I’m still really loving it.

By Kazuma Ogiwara and CARIMARICA. Released in Japan as “Isekai Toushou no Maken Seisaku Gurashi” by Kadokawa Books. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Ryan Burris.

We’re very used to seeing light novel titles where “the title is the plot” by now. They’ve become a joke now, usually involving a long title, a colon, and an even longer subtitle. The Bladesmith’s Enchanted Weapons does not have such a long title, but it falls under this category as well, as by now every volume’s plot has been set into motion by Lutz crafting a weapon, Gerhard enchanting it, and chaos accidentally springing from giving it to someone. The Japanese title translates a bit longer, but that also brings up something odd: it distinctly called Lutz an “isekai blacksmith”, but so far there’s nothing whatsoever indicating that’s true. Indeed, the third volume hammers home even more that Lutz’s father lived in this world and died in it. What seems to be the “isekai” part is simply that they’re making katanas, rather than the usual fantasy broadswords. The smithing technique is from another world… and it’s causing just as much of a mess as any potato-kun making mayonnaise does.

Last time I said I hope things would be a little better in the next book for Princess Listill, and I guessed I jinxed myself, as she really doesn’t have a good book. She’s on her way to visit Claudia, who she now regards as a big sister, when she’s kidnapped by bandits, who kill her guard knights and drive off the servants going with her. Given that she wouldn’t have been kidnapped if she weren’t going to visit Shander in the first place, the count sends an elite team to rescue her… and Lutz goes along as well, of course. She is rescued, and even manages to not get raped, because the bandits are ex-soldiers who were treated like murderers after the war ended, and are just trying to air their grievances before the king. Sadly, while their grievances are aired, the rumor mill is what it is, so everyone assumed the worst happened to the Princess, who is now “used goods”. And then things get worse.

In case you were wondering, rest assured Claudia is in this book a lot, and she and Lutz have a very active love life. She’s also good at strategy… though not as good as she thinks she is. I appreciated that the end of this volume showed that while Claudia is very clever, she still lacks experience and can be, as she disparagingly says, only good for her big, stupid butt. (Which is mentioned more than once – this author knows their audience). It’s not only her fault, though – Lutzx has got to start making katanas that turn everyone who gets them a bit crazy, because it’s starting to actually influence the politics of the region. And I didn’t even mention the secondary plot, a horror story where the dungeon in their domain has been seeing a lot of missing adventurers and a lot of mysterious jewels… or things that look like jewels.

This continues to be a series that you mostly read if you like watching guys acting cool. There’s a lot of that here. I quite like it.