Category Archives: executioner and her way of life

The Executioner and Her Way of Life: Curtain Call

By Mato Sato and nilitsu. Released in Japan as “Shokei Shoujo no Virgin Road” by GA Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Jenny McKeon.

Siiiiiigh. I should not really be surprised, but this final volume of The Executioner and Her Way of Life turned out much like many of the previous ones I’ve read. It had a slow start that made me want to skim, an interesting middle bit where I thought it might achieve something, and a disappointing ending where the author doesn’t really give the readers the resolution they want. It’s a bit of a mess, and I guess that fits. Fortunately, there are good bits in the middle. Also fortunately, the characters that I didn’t want to die don’t. But the epilogue has a bit of an “and the adventure continues” feel to it, like you might see in a Shonen Jump anime cancelled prematurely. “Rest assured, everything is still happening much the same.” That said, if there’s one character I blame for this disappointing final volume it’s Gadou. She’s a pill, she’s not fun to read, and she’s brought along her evil alternate self. She sucks.

We pick up right where we left off, with Menou and company trying to defeat Hakua, despite Hakua being nearly omnipotent. They finally manage to do this, mostly thanks to Akari snapping out of her funk, but end up getting pulled into… modern Japan? Well, not quite. It’s a modern Japan that’s basically been set up as a perfect environment for Hakua, now the teenager who was in hospital her entire life, to “get well” and go to school, make friends, etc. Sadly for Hakua, Menou, Akari, and Gadou are also in this reality… and another person, who allows our favorite princess her own life back but decides instead to go body-hopping and ruin everything in this reality just to try to kill Gadou. And look, I get that, it’s Gadou. But this is still a tantrum. Can Menou fix everything, save Hakua, and return to their own world with Akari?

To get to bits I liked: the brief look at Akari’s awful life before she ended up isekai’d was quite effective, and helps tie in to a scene later on when she has to deal with Hakua’s new reality, which is definitely NOT the Japan she was taken from. Hakua’s plotline in general was also handled well, and was probably my favorite part of the book, giving a definite closure to her story. But the epilogue was just meh. Everyone’s cleaning up after the events of the previous ten books. There are still splinter terrorist groups, so Menou and Momo are still basically fantasy cops, now helped by Akari and Ashuna. As for the yuri, no change there. Momo and Akari still love Menou, but that’s as far as it goes, and everything stays status quo. I was vaguely amused at Maya, who no longer has to be a little kid forever, suddenly shooting up like a weed. And it’s kind of amusing seeing Sahara, who is a born administrator, whine about how she can’t stop administrating.

Really, I can’t quite explain why the ending didn’t land for me, except it didn’t. If you watched the anime and wonder what happens next, I’d recommend fanfics.

The Executioner and Her Way of Life: Otherworlders Must Die

By Mato Sato and nilitsu. Released in Japan as “Shokei Shoujo no Virgin Road” by GA Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Jenny McKeon.

So let’s get the bad news out of the way, and it’s not really a spoiler. This volume came out in Japan on the same day as the 11th and final volume did, and they are clearly meant to be read as a pair – the author even says so in the afterword, which at least Yen translates properly. Unfortunately, that’s not Yen’s policy. On the bright side, the 11th and final volume *is* on the schedule, so we know vaguely when it will be coming out – six months from now. So you are reading half a book, and the ending is very abrupt. On the bright side, we’re pretty much in the home stretch, and as such the author does not have to faff around and delay things until the second half of the book as they normally do. This is a very solid volume, possibly the best to date, and folks who do choose to read it now and then wait will be quite satisfied. Lots of folks are cool, even the ones who don’t think they will be.

After the events of the last book, Menou is back to normal, Akari is back to normal, and Momo is cranky. Which is to say, she’s as normal as ever. Heck, even Ashuna, after making me worry for the cliffhanger of the last book, is pretty much back to normal. Which is good, as they’ll need everyone at their best to try to deal with both Hakua and Pandæmonium. It’s time to plan. Unfortunately, after the events of the last few books, Akari is no longer in control of time, but she can do a few things. Momo, of course, can kick ass. Sahara… exists. And then there’s Maya, who has the perfect plan – sacrifice herself to get rid of Pandæmonium. It *is* a sensible plan if you support the needs of the many philosophy, but after watching Menou do the same thing recently, I don’t think it’s where we want to go. They do have a complicated plan, which will send Pandæmonium back to Japan… leaving them to fight Hakua. Who decides to show Akari her tragic backstory.

I’ve made no secret of my favorite character in this series, and I was absolutely over the moon with how she was handled here. Sahara is grumpy and dour and wants to run away, and that doesn’t change. She also hates herself, as she’s made explicitly clear in this volume. But there is one thing that has changed, and that’s what makes her – finally – take a stand and fight. As for Menou and Akari, they’re both clearly still in love, much to Momo’s displeasure, but Hakua has just as much a right to Akari, seeing as they knew each other in Japan. Hakua’s backstory has a lot of stuff we suspected or could guess – and there’s some really disturbing stuff that does right back to the gimmick this series became known for – but it also shows how these powers everyone has are too easily corruptible. Gotta do something about that.

But we gotta wait, even if in Japan could could just reach for the next book. So goes life. This is a top-notch entry in the series, though.

The Executioner and Her Way of Life: Wish Upon a Star, Pray to a Flower

By Mato Sato and nilitsu. Released in Japan as “Shokei Shoujo no Virgin Road” by GA Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Jenny McKeon.

Well, back to reality. After a volume where I actually managed to enjoy it from beginning to end, we’re back to business as usual for The Executioner and Her Way of Life. The first 40% or so of this book is absolutely dire, and I was once again wondering why I had not dropped the series. The difficulty is that most of the people who remain in the cast are profoundly unlikable and selfish, and it’s not fun to read about them. This is also a book whose plot synopsis can best be summed up as “everyone is ignoring everyone else’s feelings and desires for the sake of their own”. Now, frequently this is understandable. The color soldiers are looking for a new homeland, and worry that this will cause the humans to try to eradicate them. (Correctly.) And Menou’s grand plan for saving Akari amounts to “kill myself”, so it’s not surprising that Momo is not down with that. Everyone is, frankly, at the end of their tether, and it shows.

Menou, Maya, and Sahara have fled to the Mechanical Society with Abbie’s help, but Michele, Momo and Hooseyard are hot on their trail, and trying to work out a way to break in there. Menou’s goal is the Starseed, but things prove more complicated than expected when they discover that another one of the Four Evils, Gadou, is still alive. After dealing with the fact that Gadou has literal split personalities, Menou puts her plan into action, despite the fact that her memory has gotten so bad that she’s forgotten Flare, Momo, and everything else about her past. Momo, meanwhile, has an Akari-in-a-Box, and a plan to get Menou and Akari both back with their memories attached, but this plan sort of relies on killing Menou first. Just for a bit. A little killing.

This book really does get good in the second half, as everyone starts to fight for their lives and their goals, and realize that there’s no way that everyone can end this alive. Indeed, Menou’s self-hatred and death wish is about all that’s fueling her now, and it helps the reader to sympathize with Momo a great deal, even when she tries to solve a problem by taking Akari from her luggage and hurling her at Menou’s head. Momo and Akari still hate each other, for obvious reasons. That said, Momo’s plan wouldn’t have worked without Akari, so they can at least be grateful for that. By the end of this book, most of the cast are almost back to normal and we’re at the end of the arc. If only Ashuna were back in the series I’d be perfectly happy. (Monkey’s Paw twitches) Oh no…

So yeah, Ashuna is the cliffhanger, and I am no longer happy. I suspect in this world that runs on war, death, and genocide, a lot of other people aren’t going to be happy either. Still, at least with Menou and Akari back to normal, there’s potential for more yuri in Book 10. Recommended, but be prepared for the traditional slow start. Also, warning, this book contains Hooseyard, and she’s still really annoying.