Category Archives: reviews

Rascal Does Not Dream of His Girlfriend

Leave a reply

By Hajime Kamoshida and Keji Mizoguchi. Released in Japan as “Seishun Buta Yarou wa Girlfriend no Yume wo Minai” by Dengeki Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Andrew Cunningham.

If you remember my reviews of titles like Babel and Unnamed Memory, you may recall that I yelled at the author and the publisher (Dengeki Bunko) for taking what could easily be two books, divided in half neatly, and making them one huge 400-page monster. This book has the exact opposite problem. The digital version is a mere 139 pages long, and that’s counting the table of contents and the (one) color illustration. I wondered if it was a case where the final volume was too long to combine them, but no, the final volume seems to be the same size as this one. This should have been one book, but it is two, with this the first half. I get the sense, judging by the very minimal illustrations, that there were production issues, but it’s still a mostly frustrating volume where Sakuta has his latest crisis happen, wanders around talking for a while, and then has the series’ Deus Ex Machina help him figure out the issue… but not solve it. Yet.

We start this book with Sakuta having done everything possible to ensure that the dream everyone had of Mai announcing that she’s Touko will not come true. Guess what happens. What’s worse, this new reality sees EVERYONE’S dreams come true. Rio is dating Yuuma, Kaede is somehow now two people, both of whom are living a happy fulfilled life, Tomoe is now going to his college next term, etc. And none of them know reality is different, and none of them want to help him fix it. Fortunately, there is one other person who is unaffected by the Touko dream virus, and it’s very thematically appropriate. They manage to take a Sakuta who is at the end of his rope (in a mild-mannered way) and lead him to the main issue, as well as help him see who’s really behind everything we’ve seen in the last five books.

Despite my carping above, this is not a bad volume, just a mostly frustrating one. The revelations, as well as the one who is giving them, are thematically appropriate, and it’s nice to see Sakuta try his usual “walk around and mope at people until he figures things out” and have it not work at all. Turns out when people have their dream come true, they actually are happy and satisfied with it. Hell, some of the dreams might be the readers’ as well. I cannot think that Saki has any fans who are desperately unhappy that she’s broken up with Yuuma, and even Sakuta admits he’s happier with that outcome as well. (We do briefly see Saki, who is NOT happy with that outcome.) Even Kaede, who would be the one most torn by her incompatible dreams, literally becomes two people to fix everything. Mai is still in love with Sakuta and his girlfriend, she’s just also Touko. Everyone is happy and content. Except Sakuta. And the other two people I deliberately waffled around in the second paragraph.

So the next volume is the last, though there’s already an After Story volume out as well, apparently. I assume, this having mostly been all setup, it will be all payoff. This was good. Should have been combined with the next book.

Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? Minor Myths and Legends, Vol. 2

Leave a reply

By Fujino Omori and nilitsu. Released in Japan as “Dungeon ni Deai o Motomeru no wa Machigatte Iru Darou ka? Shohenshu” by GA Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Jake Humphrey.

If you thought it was hard for me to write 500 words or so on the first SS collection, imagine how hard it’s going to be with this one, where I can’t even waste 100 of them describing what it is. That said, at least here there is slightly less of the “everybody loves Bell” show, mostly as he’s far more of a supporting character. These short stories, with one or two exceptions, focus on Loki Familia, and the majority are about either Aiz or Lefiya. Which means it is about romance somewhat – after all, Lefiya has a crush on Aiz at this point in the story (the stories go up to the 12th volume), and Aiz has vaguely warm feelings for Bell. Both of them have something in common, which is they can’t quite work out what Bell is to them. Lefiya settles on rival, and Aiz, strangely, settles on rabbit, but they’re both watching him dash ahead and wanting that.

The cover shows Aiz and Lyu, possibly as this also takes in the first Lyu volume and the Freya volume. That said, those wanting lots of Lyu will be disappointed. Most of these, as with the first, are 1-2 page stories that don’t impact much. They’re also mostly comedic, again with one or two exceptions, usually focusing on Leene, that one character we got to know well before she was brutally murdered. There are larger stories in here as well, which focus on Loki Familiar catching a unicorn, Tiona and her book nerd friendship with Bell, a romcom disaster set around the events of DanMachi 7/DanMachi SO 8, Aiz dreaming of various pasts and futures she could have, Aiz walking around the city talking with most of the regular cast and trying to figure out her own heart, a sequel to the Freya book focusing on Shalzad’s new king, and seeming to tie into Memoria Freese, and the last story, which I’ll go into below.

The final story takes place sometime after DanMachi 19 and Sword Oratoria 13, but not much longer after. It starts off silly, tying back to the first SS collection as Loki Familia are looking at the “character poll” and Lefiya is getting very, very angry that Bell beat Aiz in some categories. She goes off to find out who was responsible for this travesty… and runs into Syr, who is spreading the word of Bell, partly as part of her punishment (which goes over Lefiya’s head, as she missed everything and has no idea why Syr is) and partly as she’s still madly in love with Bell. Meanwhile, Aiz ends up running into Ryu, and the two are super awkward around each other, especially when they recall their first meeting. Naturally, the four eventually come together. This, the most recent story (it was written for the book itself) mostly made me happy as it shows that Syr is not going to just be a meek little good girl, even though she’s given up being Freya. She’s here to spread the word of Bell, and if Lefiya says “rival” and Aiz says “rabbit”, well, that’s fine with her.

So this was solid, but again, for fans only. Next up should be Sword Oratoria 14.

I’ll Become a Villainess Who Goes Down in History: It Seems Turning into a High-Born Baddie Makes the Prince All the More Lovestruck, Vol. 2

Leave a reply

By Izumi Okido and Jyun Hayase. Released in Japan as “Rekishi ni Nokoru Akujo ni Naru zo: Akuyaku Reijō ni Naru hodo Ōji no Dekiai wa Kasoku suru yō desu!” by B’s-LOG Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Sarah Moon.

I’ve said about a lot of light novel series that reach a second volume that they have the same issue that bands have when they reach that “difficult second album” – they struggle to figure out what to do next. I don’t think that’s the issue here, as I think the author has a definite long-term plan in mind. The trouble is that it is a long-term plan, and I suspect they definitely have “Alicia does something so annoying she gets exiled” for Book Three. As such, a lot of this book seems to be treading water a bit, showing us Alicia being gleefully “villainessey”, and Liz still trying to be an idealist even as events are starting to conspire against her. And this is despite the fact that someone appears to be trying to swing events back towards the game by having the Saint attacked by a horrible beast.

Two years after exiling herself to a small cottage on the family property, with no one allowed to see her, Alicia has finally reached Level 91, allowing her to keep up with the Level 100 Liz. She celebrates by heading over to the village where she can use powerful magic to partially restore Will’s sight… by literally giving him one of her own eyes. Feeling proud, she then unfortunately realizes this has taken all her magic, and it’ll be a week before she can use it again. And so she has to hide from her father, who will no doubt test her Level 91-ness. She does this by going back to school, only to find that while she was gone, and theoretically not able to influence anything, her reputation has gotten MUCH WORSE, and she’s almost the boogeyman now.

As I said, a lot of this seems to be delaying tactics, as we see various arrogant noble girls (or wannabe arrogant noble girls) trying to either attack and defame Alicia or try to get her on their side so that they can trick and defame her later. For the most part Alicia is too clever for any of this to work, but it does give her the opportunity to give herself a cool haircut and give a bullied girl a magical crying room (we are even explicitly told said crying girl is gay, though I suspect it’s less for representation and more to show that Even The Girls Want Her in a tropey way.) Of course there’s also her relationship with Duke, where he’s very clearly in love with her, and says so, and she’s also clearly in love with him, but knows that loving him is bad for the country and bad for her plan. She’s too pragmatic to give in to romance.

As I said, all signs point to the third book throwing Alicia into the enemy country she wants to investigate. Till then, this was pretty good, but felt sort of formless.