Category Archives: reviews

My Next Life As a Villainess: All Routes Lead to Doom!, Vol. 14

By Satoru Yamaguchi and Nami Hidaka. Released in Japan as “Otome Game no Hametsu Flag Shika Nai Akuyaku Reijou ni Tensei Shite Shimatta…” by Ichijinsha Bunko Iris. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Joshua Douglass-Molloy.

This is one of the lengthier volumes in the series, as the author notes in their afterword. That said, by the end of it, there’s really only one new piece of information, and I’m not sure where we’re going to go with it. The rest of the book is made up of the usual romantic stasis (Jeord, having once again forced a kiss, ends up getting a fever and taking the rest of the volume off), with one exception that I’ll get to. And there’s also the continuing story of what’s going on with all the black magic and who’s behind it, which we get closer to, but have not quite arrived at an endgame. In other words, this volume is full of sound and fury. That said, Katarina’s clueless narration is always pleasant, and the book is definitely fun to read much of the time. But as always, anyone who came to this from the anime has likely dropped it ages ago.

Katarina and the others attend a palace ball, and given that Maria and her family were recently attacked, this includes extra bodyguarding in Cyrus, who is forced to have to deal with women. Katarina, meanwhile, is delighted to find a kindred spirit, as another woman is also eating far too much food and being chided by her brother for it. This is Haru and her brother Ryo, and as the names might have suggested, they’re from this world’s version of Japan. And, the two plots dovetailing nicely, it turns out that Haru is in love with Cyrus, and has been lurking around palace balls trying to pin him down. This all culminates in a visit to Cyrus’ lands, which are having a disturbingly familiar problem… animals are disappearing from the nearby forest. Is Katarina going to have to fight another dragon?

I try not to be a shipper in these reviews, but sorry, a great deal of this book is devoted to setting up Maria and Cyrus, which is naturally going to make my MariKata heart sad. Katarina, as ever, is very canny about everyone else’s romantic relationships but not her own – she even pegs Haru as the second’ otome game’s version of Mary, and she’s absolutely correct, right down to the rejection that inevitably comes. The key difference between Fortune Lover I and II in Katarina’s universe is that unlike the first book, where almost all the events were killed off by Katarina’s niceness, the second game’s events are actually happening, making it harder for her to avoid her doom. Though she’ll give it a try, as long as she can use her magical staff like a vacuum cleaner (the best part of the book).

The big revelation here is that Sarah, our increasingly distressed villain, is a childhood friend of Raphael’s “alter ego” Sirius. How that plays out will need to wait for the next book. For hardcore fans.

I’m the Villainess, So I’m Taming the Final Boss, Vol. 10

By Sarasa Nagase and Mai Murasaki. Released in Japan as “Akuyaku Reijo Nanode Rasubosu o Katte Mimashita” by Kadokawa Beans Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Taylor Engel.

Just when you thought it was safe to forget about otome games… Yes, that’s right. We had the main game that Aileen needed to destroy. Then we had the sequel. Then we had the other sequel. Then we had the fandisk. But at last, they have run out of game to use, and Aileen and Claude can relax and get down to the important business of Aileen giving birth. Unfortunately, guess what? That’s right, it turns out there’s another game, seemingly unrelated, but in reality it ties into all the other games in a very “legal grey area” sort of way. And you know what that means. War with Ellmeyer, Claude being offered an out by marrying someone else, and Aileen being offered certain death. It’s a bit less “if I make one wrong move I’ll be executed” this time around – Aileen is an old hand at this sort of thing by now – but it’s nice to get back to the basics.

Claude is off to the Kilvas Empire, and for once, Aileen is not coming along. She’s pregnant, after all, and all the games that could destroy her life have been conquered, so what’s to worry about? Oh dear. As it turns out, as noted above, we’re headed into the plot of Valkyrie of the Magic Lance, and Lilia is DELIGHTED to tell Aileen all about it, gleefully noting all the ways that the entire country could be plunged into chaos. So naturally Aileen does have to come along, promising to be very careful, of course. They’re there to attend a wedding of Vica, a young man who looks a lot like Claude, and Diana, a military Valkyrie who seems a bit… obsessive? Aileen being Aileen, she decides to pretend she’s an airheaded trophy wife, and discovers that Diana has secret plans… which involve a military coup.

Diana is one of the more unpleasant women we’ve run into in this series, and since it’s a 2-parter that will conclude with the 11th (and final) volume, we get pretty much no softening of her at all. Instead, we get a few hints that she’s the same as Aileen and Lilia – that is, she’s a Japanese reincarnation. Sadly, she’s also a bit of an idiot, thinking that everyone will just move all the budget of her empire to the military with no arguments. Vica is far more interesting, as he’s Claude’s mirror in many ways, and the two can’t help but feel sympathetic towards each other. And then there’s Aileen, who promises to take it easy, and then does not remotely take it easy. Fortunately, the kid inside her seems of hardy stock. Those who read this book to see Aileen be clever, figure things out, and then leave it all for Claude to do the heavy work while she manages everything behind the scenes will be delighted.

The book ends with (of course) Aileen and Lilia giving birth at the exact same time to twin daughters. (Lilia literally says that she thinks of her child as the result of her relationship with Aileen. Poor Cedric.) Unfortunately, the bad guys got away at the end of this book. So I’m sure Book 11 will have Aileen fighting her fate again.

Loner Life in Another World, Vol. 12

By Shoji Goji and Saku Enomaru. Released in Japan as “Hitoribocchi no Isekai Kouryaku” by Overlap Bunko. Released in North America by Airship. Translated by Andrew Schubauer.

Given that a large chunk of this series consists entirely of the same goddamn thing over and over again (Haruka going from level to level of a dungeon, battling monsters, and gaining new power-ups/items), I hope you won’t be too disappointed that I talk about things I’ve talked about in previous reviews. The series’ reputation, both here and in Japan – indeed, more in Japan than here – is that its writing is incoherent and obtuse. This is true. It’s also clear that the author is trying, and slightly succeeding, in making that deliberate. Haruka is so busy telling us about the stream of church guards that he and Nefertiri are slaughtering and the cool +30 Eccentric Item Set A he’s acquired that he glosses over the abused, mentally broken slaves they’re freeing as they do this, the sheer fury that they’ve got on their faces, and Haruka’s battle with trying to save everyone and not destroy his body. Oh, and his depression. Which he hints at briefly. Once.

Haruka and Nefertiri are sneaking into the Cathedral, there to essentially take down the church. On the way there, Haruka comes across a gorgeous woman in a coffin… but he’s just her dead body, there’s no soul. What’s more, seeing her makes Nefertiri start to cry, though she can’t quite remember why. They have to deal with a lot of goons, a lot of monsters (including the husband of his chickenatrice), and the mother of the bunny girl and wolf girl from the previous book, who was tricked by the church and is now in cursed armor. That said, killing the pope and the evil clergy only turns out to be part one of what they need to do, as there’s another dungeon emperor, and Haruka is pretty sure that if he finds them he’ll find the soul that belongs to the body he found earlier.

Haruka’s exterior face and tone when others see him talking don’t always match his narrative blather. Class Rep and the others are used to seeing when he’s actually serious and when he’s just being a loon, but the reader sees it less frequently. That’s why the highlight of the book, frankly, is his confrontation with Faleria, the aforementioned Dungeon Emperor and holy saint, who is drowning herself in guilt and asks Haruka to kill her. You can imagine how well he takes this, and for once it actually shows, as he literally slams her head against a wall multiple times to get her to accept that the people whose lives she is mourning would not want her to simply give up on her own life – indeed, the plot of this entire book was engineered centuries ago in the hopes that someone will come along to save her. Haruka’s not going to let anyone around him (especially a woman) be anything less than insanely happy. And yes, that’s why she falls in love with him.

There’s the usual character bio errors (what is it with these? It’s not just Seven Seas, all the publishers struggle immensely with matching a character bio with the picture), but otherwise this is well adapted… I’d say it reads smoothly but you know it doesn’t, and that’s by design. In any case, next time will likely be Haruka trying to fix his new body, which lacks all the stuff he learned before, so I expect *even more* dungeon crawling and *even more* sex. Recommended for masochists who like puzzles.