A Certain Magical Index, Vol. 16

Leave a reply

By Kazumi Kamachi and Kiyotaka Haimura. Released in Japan as “To Aru Majutsu no Index” by ASCII Mediaworks. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Andrew Prowse.

Given the events of the last volume, and the fact that the cover art looks for all the world like a fun romantic comedy, I imagine the average reader went into this book thinking it would be a nice, relaxing volume. And it is… for about the first quarter of the book. Then Acqua of the Back arrives, and everything pretty much goes to hell. But hey, at least this book has Touma and Index in it, right? Well, not so much. Index is once again relegated to comic relief (she even lampshades how useful she WOULD have been after everything has already happened), and Touma is removed from most of the fighting by, yet again, half-fatal injuries. No, this book is about the Amakusa Church, their guilt-driven Saint Kaori Kanzaki, and their #1 Touma fan Itsuwa, who can cook, clean, is pretty with a nice chest, wields a spear magnificently, and loves Touma. In fact, in a series filled with heroines with major faults, her main fault may be not having one.

Introduced in this book: Fiamma of the Right, the “Knight Leader”, and the Third English Princess, whose name I will hold off on till I see how Yen romanizes it. This takes place about three days after Touma and Index get back from France. Touma is starting to worry about his attendance credits, and well he should – he’s barely been in class this semester. We have basically passed all the Index spinoff titles in terms of chronology. There are, of course, several ongoing plot threads from previous books. Itsuwa is dispatched to be Touma’s bodyguard after the events of tBook 14 (and so that the Amakusa Church can try to get them together as a couple, something doomed to failure). Acqua’s threat to Touma a couple books ago is carried out here, and he very nearly succeeds. And Mikoto has found out about Touma’s amnesia, and it’s bothering her, mostly as she’s not sure when it happened.

This book, as with a lot of shonen titles, is about seeing people who are so much better, faster, and stronger than you, and then getting up and fighting anyway because it’s right. Acqua doesn’t care what Touma’s motivations or desires are – his hand is a weapon, and therefore he treats Touma the same way. (Honestly, given the last two members of God’s Right Seat, he’s the least villainous, but that’s only by degree.) Itsuwa and the rest of the Amakusa fight because they know Touma is a good person, right hand or no. And Kaori leaps in to fight because Acqua is about to kill the rest of the Amakusa, and she may be keeping her distance from them but she still wants to protect them. In fact, arguably it’s Kaori who learns the biggest lesson here – no, not Tsuchimikado’s stupid ero maid thing, which made my teeth grind. But you can’t protect the ones you love from the shadows and by pushing them away. It only hurts them more. Seeing Kaori and the Amakusa team up was absolutely the highlight of this book, and I like that for once Touma did not get in the final blow (or even break any illusions), though he certainly made it possible.

It appears we’re going to be focusing on England next time (and watch out for Fiamma describing how to bring the island nation down to its knees in a way that sounds suspiciously similar to a no-deal Brexit). Also, I worry my discussion of the lack of a role for Index and her desire to help more may change for the worse soon – it sounds like Fiamma’s big plan is basically to capture her. In any case, though Kamachi remains as bad as ever at wacky harem antics, this is still an excellent volume of Index.

That Blue Sky Feeling, Vol. 1

Leave a reply

By Okura and Coma Hashii. Released in Japan as “Sorairo Flutter” by Square Enix, serialization ongoing in the magazine Gangan Joker. Released in North America by Viz Media. Translated by Jocelyne Allen.

When I first saw the cover for this manga on preordering it, my thought was “Boy, that guy sure is excited”. And that’s a pretty good description of the first volume. Noshiro, the guy punching the air on the cover, is just a big bundle of energetic, outgoing “HI THERE”, and you can’t help but be carried along in his wake. Even when he’s being introspective, angry, or doubting himself, it’s filled with big, energetic emotions and movements. This is, of course, to contrast him with the series’ other lead, Sanada, who is introverted, quiet, doesn’t smile much – at least at first – and is the very definition of standoffish. Most of the book is devoted to Noshiro’s arrival in Sanada’s life, and his reaction and actions on hearing the rumor going around the school, which is that Sanada is actually gay. A rumor that Sanada later confirms to Noshiro.

Most of the rest of the volume focuses on Noshiro’s developing reaction to this news, although honestly the book is as much about Sanada as an introvert as it is about Sanada as a young gay man. Sanada’s childhood friend Yamamoto has always come to eat with him (and might have a crush on him), but seems delighted that he’s finally making another friend, and tries to support Noshiro’s attempts to batter his way into Sanada’s life. But Sanada’s introversion and his sexuality aren’t easily separated either, and even being introverted isn’t always black and white. We see Sanada meet some old friends from junior high, and he’s smiling and laughing with them in a way he doesn’t seem to with Noshiro. This leads both Noshiro and Yamamoto to wonder if Sanada is “faking it” in front of them – something which Sanada rebuts, saying that both aspects of him are “real”.

We also meet Hidemitsu in this story, an older man who Sanada describes as “sort of an ex-boyfriend”. The fact that Sanada is still a high school boy is briefly brought up and then shunted aside, but I will hold off on objections till I see how close they actually were. For the moment Hidemitsu functions as an advisor and mentor to both Sanada and Noshiro, having a mature wisdom that both of them lack at this point. It also is fairly obvious that Hidemitsu and Noshiro look a whole lot alike, and that a lot of Sanada’s standoffishness may simply be attraction. Noshiro’s sexuality hasn’t come up much – he finds it difficult to name a specific girl he’s attracted to in a “guy conversation”, and has no romantic experience – but I suspect we may delve further into that in future volumes.

Honestly, the best thing about this ongoing coming-of-age story is simply how well-written it is. The characters are likeable, they have good depth, and you care about them. It feels very real. I absolutely recommend it.

Baccano!: 1934 Alice in Jails: Prison

Leave a reply

By Ryohgo Narita and Katsumi Enami. Released in Japan by ASCII Mediaworks. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Taylor Engel.

Having just finished a two-volume arc, we immediately jump into a THREE-volume arc, which consists of the two Alice in Jails book and a third called Peter Pan in Chains. As the names might indicate, Alice in Chains is the title quote, so to speak, but the book itself also revolves around jail, specifically Alcatrax, which in 1934 was still fairly new as a prison for hardcore felons (as opposed to a military prison). The description of the prison itself is quite good, showing it as an unpleasant place that can break a man, as well as being well-nigh impossible to escape from. After being blackmailed with Ennis’ safety, Firo is sent to infiltrate the prison to try to talk to its most infamous resident: Huey Laforet, who is kept in solitary confinement in the lowest of basements. But he’s not alone. Isaac has been sent there for some odd reason, and one of the prisoners already there is well known to us: Ladd Russo. Has he gotten any less violent and manic? No.

This book was, I believe, being written at the same time as the anime was being planned, and discusses certain events that the reader is unaware of but the characters aren’t, such as Graham Specter, who is introduced in this book but unseen, or the mention of a Mr. St. Germain at the Daily Days, who is also as yet unseen. The book also flits back and forth between Firo’s adventures in prison and the rest of the cast back in New York, who are dealing with Huey Laforet, despite being in prison, apparently planning a large scale terrorist attack. Narita enjoys setting up mystifying things only to have them pay off one or two books down the road, so we need to settle in here. There’s also some events from previous books intruding – the coverup of the Flying Pussyfoot murders is mentioned a few times, and we meet Gustavo, the pathetic villain from Drugs and the Dominoes, who is essentially here to be Ladd’s ticket to Alcatraz, and boy does he deserve it.

I want to talk about Isaac and Miria, though, as this is in some ways my favorite book with them, despite their not being major players in it. They’ve been wonderfully funny comic relief most of the time, but in the last arc we got some hints of deeper things – Miria’s monologue in the color pages. Now here we see that neither of them are as “stupid” as they may outwardly seem. Isaac’s ability to identify he’s talking to a cop and get Miria out of danger is masterful, and the rest of the Martillos rightly boggle at it. We also get into his head a little bit at the end, as it’s made clear he grew up in San Francisco right near Alcatraz… though he doesn’t want to see his family. As for Miria (whose head we don’t really get into), not only does she go to Ronny first to help her try to save Isaac, but she actually seems to know he’s a demon. But the best scene for Miria, in my opinion, is the one with Chane, where the two of them comfort each other over their most important person being in Alcatraz, and Miria shows off her empathy – I liked how she immediately knew how Chane communicated and wasn’t uncomfortable with it. Terrific character work here.

This is one of the better Baccano! books, including a great twist at the end I’ve tried not to spoil, and fans will absolutely want to get it. Next time we should actually meet Gustav St. Germain, as well as the much mentioned but unseen Graham, who I suspect may have been written with Norio Wakamoto and Tomokazu Sugita in mind.