By Shiki and Wan Hachipisu. Released in Japan as “Jishō Akuyaku Reijō na Tsuma no Kansatsu Kiroku” by Regina Books. Released in North America by Hanashi Media. Translated by Ethan Holms.

I will admit, this is the first volume in the series that I wasn’t that wild about. It’s still great whenever Cecil is being Cecil or Bertia is being Bertia, but I get the sense the author thought of this as a two-book arc, and was determined to keep it that way despite the fact that the second book doesn’t have nearly the interest that the first one does. The first book in the arc had a “you’ll never marry my daughter!” dad and a shut-in mom, a deadly and attractive combination. This second book has a family of mostly airheads, and also has a girl who irrationally hates Kuro. Yes, the irrational hatred is the actual plot, and it does turn out to have a reason, but it makes her annoying and easy to dislike. I admit that I was counting pages towards the end there. Fortunately, the book is still narrated by Cecil, which automatically raises it up.

Last time we met Kuro’s family, this time we meet Zeno’s. His mother is a ditz… as are his four sisters, who don’t believe he actually has a girl who likes him, so kidnap him immediately and try to get him to marry the girl they approve of – the niece of the King of Light, Light Sparrow. She’s been sickly, especially lately. She also seems to really like Zeno when she meets him… but she takes an immediate, visceral dislike of Kuro, saying that she can sense she’s evil. This goes badly. Bertia tries to handle this by showing off how cute Kuro really is, which does not work at all. Cecil tries to figure out what is making Light Sparrow sick and why she relapsed, and this goes better. Finally, they return home to a big surprise.

There were a few things I did really enjoy. The revelation of what’s wrong with Light Sparrow ties back into much earlier in the series, and while it’s a bit of a handwave solution, I appreciated how it was handled on the human end, with Cecil, despite wanting to simply ignore it, giving in to Bertia’s kindness. Speaking of things typing back to plotlines I had actually completely forgotten about, one of the minor issues in and earlier book (Bertia’s maid has a “weak presence”, which causes people to ignore her) is also given a solution stemming from the spirit world, and I did appreciate the maid’s resolute “nope” to the solution being offered. Good for her. And then there’s the ending, which is pretty telegraphed, and not entirely unexpected. I did appreciate Cecil, on hearing the news, realizing he now has TWO people to love unconditionally. Cecil is, at best, lacking empathy, so it’s nice to see he’s not going the route of, say, the lead couple in I Swear I Won’t Bother You Again!.

If you want to skip this book and start with the next one: Bertia wants to do Halloween, and Cecil will be making it more of a harvest festival with costumes. Also, she’s pregnant. This was OK.

By Shiki and Wan Hachipisu. Released in Japan as “Jishō Akuyaku Reijō na Tsuma no Kansatsu Kiroku” by Regina Books. Released in North America by Hanashi Media. Translated by Ethan Holms.

Since I last reviewed this series, the anime has debuted, and a few things are becoming clear. First of all, like many light novel adaptations, the anime is speed running things a bit, so I suspect we’ll get into the “wife” part of the series before the end of the season. Secondly, I’d forgotten how some of the characters looked at the start of the series compared with now. In the first volume, Zeno was a beleaguered but relatively calm butler who normally served to snark at Cecil when Cecil was being particularly evil. In this sixth book, Zeno is an absolute wreck of a spirit, constantly whining and yelling at everyone around him. Part of this is due to the dreaded “oh, his partner looks really young, ha ha he’s a lolicon” joke we get in light novels, which is never funny and isn’t here either. But partly it’s because family, no matter how much you may try to avoid it, will always be embarrassing.

Cecil and Bertia are home from Seahealby, and everything seems relatively peaceful. So it’s now time for Zeno to go visit the spirit kingdom, so that he can ask permission from Kuro’s parents to marry her. This isn’t required, but he wants to be polite about it. Bertia is going as Kuro is very attached to her. Cecil is going as Bertia is going. And everyone else is suffering, because Cecil was already gone for an extended period and now he’s leaving again. When they arrive, they have to deal with Zeno’s parents, who are merely very embarrassing, and who also set up the plot of the 4th book in this series, when we’ll meet his seemingly overbearing sisters. The main plot, though, has the “ha ha he’s a lolicon” jokes hit at exactly the wrong time, meaning he and Cecil are now locked out of her parent’s castle till he completes some herculean tasks. No worries, Cecil is here to help. Wait, no, here to observe.

I have to admit, the stakes in this one are pretty low, mostly because you know all that has to happen is Kuro putting her foot down and the problem is solved. Also, Bertia is mostly sidelined in this book, as she stays behind while Zeno and Cecil go off to do the plot, staying behind mostly to try to be villainous again, as Kuro’s mother hits a bunch of her “so cool!” buttons and she goes off into la-la land. (I will admit, Bertia trying to have herself get tied up is a very funny bit.) The bulk of the heavy lifting goes to Cecil, though, as is appropriate. here he’s smug, a bit sadistic, and also accidentally helps Zeno save the day. While Cecil is pretty much an expert at anything he’s ever done, he also has a fair bit of “golden boy” luck, which helps him out here. I also appreciated that Kuro’s parents end up being just as socially awkward as she is, and it explains quite a bit.

This series feels like it’s coasting, but I still like the cast, and it’s fun most of the time.

By Shiki and Wan Hachipisu. Released in Japan as “Jishō Akuyaku Reijō na Tsuma no Kansatsu Kiroku” by Regina Books. Released in North America by Hanashi Media. Translated by Ethan Holms.

Villainess stories generally tend to either be narrated entirely from the perspective of the villainess herself, or they do that thing where we get her POV for a while, then we get the POV of all her love interests going over the same ground from their perspective (see Bakarina as an example). This series, on the other hand, is entirely from the POV of Prince Cecil, which works very well, not only as he’s easily the most interesting character in the series, essentially an evil villain who has never had the “this is when I became a villain” moment, but because he does not have the memories of otome games and shoujo novels and all the other things that Bertia has that makes her act… well, “more” eccentric would be an accurate phrase. But this also means that, because he’s merely dealing with a particularly stupid foreign prince, he doesn’t realize why he’s so stupid till the final scenes of the book.

Cecil and Bertia are still in Seahealby, having spent the last book trying to heal the awkward, poor relationships between the crown prince and his fiancee and the second prince and his fiancee. Unfortunately, that leaves the first prince, and he proves to be a real piece of work. Things are not helped by Bertia, drunk off the sake that she gifted the crown prince and his wife at their wedding, accidentally giving some to a snake spirit who turns out to be the country’s god. Now the god is obsessed with Bertia, and so is the first prince, who seems to assume that Cecil and Bertia are merely tolerating each other, so essentially says to him “let me marry your wife and take her off your hands”. Cecil then destroys the entire country and kills everyone in it… well, no, but he does get very angry indeed.

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: Cecil is essentially a sociopath with minimal empathy whose sole chain linking him to being a good person is his wife, whom he adores. Every time that he gets angry because something is happening to Bertia, everyone around him recoils in horror, as his face is that of someone about to commit murders. He’s even warned not to go to Bertia right away as he’ll terrify her. That said, their relationship is mutual – thanks to the first prince’s manipulations, Bertia has a meltdown when she believes Cecil might abandon her, and he has to reassure her. There’s also a nifty twist at the end, not just because of why the first prince is the way that he is, but the fact that the shoujo novel Bertia was thinking of happens two years LATER than their current year. Once again, Bertia makes everything better by accident.

The next volume should be out after the anime premieres, and we’ll see if the anime helps or hurts it. I’m enjoying it a great deal, at any rate.