By Mary=Doe and Kuga Huna. Released in Japan as “Akuyaku Reijou no Kyouji” by SQEX Novel. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Bérénice Vourdon.

Last time I asked what the author was going to do to continue what was an obviously complete story beyond the first volume. The answer ends up being escalation, in every possible way. Did the first volume have a villainess archetype? Let’s add a couple more! Are there obvious schemes to save the day by sacrificing oneself? Let’s double down on making it even more convoluted. The author wanted to see how many gambit balls they could keep in the air at once, and the answer turns out to be “a lot”. Fortunately, they have the skills to back this up – this is excellent. Mostly as, like the first volume, most of the cast have genuinely well-thought out motivation and gripping backstory, rather than just being “wait, she’s a pink-haired baron’s daughter who’s a saint candidate? Must be evil.” And fear not, Wellmy is back, ans she’s got a plan. Unfortunately, while her plan is very, very clever, it still runs into quite a few snags, because of the “antagonist’s” plan.

Darristea, a duke’s daughter, has been having a bad time of it. Long assumed to be the obvious fiancee candidate for her childhood friend Leo, he’s now going around with the horrible Wellmy, who everyone knows is a villainess. Worse, Wellmy has a posse of men around her at all times. Could she be using… mind control magic? Then another noble, Lord Turgis, gives her a device that will force Wellmy to tell the truth. It’s a perfect scheme! …except, of course, that this is all part of a wheels-within-wheels plan which Darristea has unfortunately gotten caught up in. Worse, Theresalo, the aforementioned baron’s daughter and saint candidate, is being blackmailed into an attack on Prince Leo as well. With all of these potential villainesses running around, is there room for Wellmy to quietly save the country and make her sister happy, not in that order?

As with the first book, there’s a lot less suspense in this than you’d expect. The main question is not really “what’s happening” but “how many people are trying to throw themselves under a bus to save someone else?”. Also as with the first book, it’s divided into the first half (Wellmy’s scheme and how it plays out) and the second half (other character’s POV explaining bits we may not have known about and wrapping up various romantic pairings. The main villain proves to be almost as interesting as Wellmy was, though I will admit there was one plot point, involving his motivation and how to fix it, that made me think that was one handwave too many. There’s also some funny stuff here, from Theresalo gradually realizing that she’s surrounded by monsters who will one day rule the world to Wellmy finding that there are some people whose emotional state she cannot, in fact, read. And while the romance still isn’t the point of this series, this book is drenched in it, with couples galore.

So all is well, and Leo is finally able to officially announce that Wellmy’s sister is his fiancee. I’m sure that they’ll all live happily ever… what’s that, you say? Trusted servants? There’s a notable lack thereof? Guess we need a third book. Recommended to all fans of the genre, or just really good books.

By Mary=Doe and Kuga Huna. Released in Japan as “Akuyaku Reijou no Kyouji” by SQEX Novel. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Bérénice Vourdon.

It’s always interesting seeing a Villainess title on the Club side of J-Novel rather than the Heart side. Usually it means that the romance isn’t the point of the exercise, and that is the case here, though that might surprise you after you see what the plot is, as there is an awful lot of romance in this book. But in the end this isn’t a romance as much as a twisted caper film. Our protagonist has a goal, that will take years and involves lots of moving parts, and eventually everything comes together until she’s able to pull off the goal… or at least, she hopes that’s what happens. Heck, since she’s not reincarnated from Japan, this doesn’t even have to involve a game world at all, and there’s no pesky heroine either. There’s just two sisters, with one of them being noble and abused and the other being arrogant and haughty. All is as it should be… except, as you may have gathered by the title, the other sister is the main character.

We open the way a lot of villainess books open – with the seeming romantic lead cruelly breaking off his engagement to his poor fiancee. However, we see this from the perspective of Iora’s sister Wellmy. While Iora has been abused by her parents, barely fed, forced to live apart from the main house, and essentially tortured, Wellmy has had it good. The best dresses, the finest jewely. She even has fantastic grades… which also happen to have her forcing her sister to write her papers for her and sign Wellmy’s name. She is every inch the terrible stepsister we see in these books, and she even manages to get Iora married off to the horrible Marquis, rumored to hate women. It is therefore no surprise whatsoever that, six months from now, Wellmy arrives at a party only to have Aides, the Marquis in question, reveal all of her horrible deeds in front of everyone. Just as Wellmy planned.

This book does have its flaws. It’s horribly overbalanced towards the front, having its climactic and best scene (the slap) only 1/4 of the way through, with over half the book devoted to looking at the “other side” of what’s been going on. It’s also clearly written as a standalone, and it is hard to see how it has 7+ volumes in Japan now, which it does. That said, I loved this to bits. Not a surprise, everything in it was designed to be catnip to me. It’s not as dark as I expected, frankly – there is a lot of funny business here, especially when Wellmy discovers her inner submissive – but there is a core of despair that falls over the main events. Wellmy’s grand plan means that she’s never considered what to do with her life besides “die”. Iora is forced to watch from afar as her sister deliberately destroys herself. Even their mother, who is written off for most of the book as a scheming woman who loathes her adopted daughter, turns out to have a terrible backstory. There are definitely reasons why Wellmy had to go so far, though in the end she and Iora reap the rewards… even if Wellmy does so reluctantly.

All this plus casual verbal abuse of a crown prince. What’s not to love? For all fans of this genre, and I hope the author can figure out what comes next.