Is It Wrong To Try To Pick Up Girls In A Dungeon? On The Side: Sword Oratoria, Vol. 13

Leave a reply

By Fujino Omori and Kiyotaka Haimura. Released in Japan as “Dungeon ni Deai o Motomeru no wa Machigatte Iru Darou ka? Gaiden – Sword Oratoria” by GA Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Dale DeLucia.

It’s been over four years since we last had a volume of Sword Oratoria, though thankfully the next two books in the series are out in Japan, so it shouldn’t be that long all the time. If the first six or so books in the series were an Aiz spinoff, the next six were, on and off, focused on Lefiya. She gets this one as well, serving as an epilogue to her arc, and showing how she’s dealing with Filvis’ death and her part in it. I will admit, I probably did myself a favor reading this book right after a volume of Tanya the Evil. That series, which it can be fascinating, is not one you read for great prose. It’s a military slog. This, on the other hand, absolutely flies by despite being almost 300 pages. Say what you will about Omori, they can write a well-paced volume. What’s more, this takes place at the same time as Vol. 19 in the main series. We’ve finally caught up.

We pick up shortly after the events of the last few books. Lefiya returns to Loki Familia, having cut her long hair short, and now equipping herself with Filvis’ sword. She needs training to get stronger so she can be a magical swordsman, she says, and she chooses to train with Bete, reasoning that he’s the only one who will beat the shit out of her till she gets stronger. Loki, realizing that Lefiya is headed down a dangerous path, instead has her go to the flying School District to scout new students for the Familia. After all, Lefiya came from that school originally. On arrival, interspersed with memories of her time as a student, she learns how to be a teacher, and also continues down her very dangerous path. Fortunately, she’s better at one of these things more than the other.

We do see Bell in this, and yes, Lefiya still hates him. (The Memoria Freese game that’s currently being mined for spinoffs suggests they go back a lot longer than either of them realize.) Lefiya and Bell have been compared and contrasted through the entire Sword Oratoria spinoff, and it’s even more clear here, as Lefiya absolutely throws herself into getting stronger so that she can carry on Filvis’ legacy. The flashbacks suggest that Lefiya lacks a goal, and that adventurers who lack goals end up dead adventurers. She’s honestly pretty terrifying in this, especially in the back half, as we realize that she’s essentially trying to commit suicide by destroying her own identity. Fortunately, the genuine teaching moments she gives to the students in her care (some of whom are older than she is) helps to save her in the end. Lefiya can’t be Filvis no matter how much she loved her (and she says it out loud here). She has to remain Lefiya. Now, at least, she can move forward.

As for the spinoff itself, the next volume moves backwards, and appears to finally show us how Finn, Gareth and Riveria ended up in Loki Familia. Till then, I will finally admit that I’ve stopped disliking Lefiya. She’s gotten good.

The Saga of Tanya the Evil: Dum Spiro, Spero, Part 1

Leave a reply

By Carlo Zen and Shinobu Shinotsuki. Released in Japan as “Youjo Senki” by Enterbrain. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by James Balzer.

It’s been 15 months since the last volume of this series in English, and this one has a new translator as well. That said, it was 42 months between the 12th and 13th volume in Japan, so I think we lucked out there. To reverse this luck, Japan got the 14th volume only one month later, whereas we have to wait another six months or so. That said, after everything happening in this volume, I’m exhausted, and don’t mind a wait. I don’t think we’re quite in the final arc of the series – the Unified States haven’t fully joined the war yet – but we’re nearly there, and this volume throws us back at the Federation/Empire conflict, with not-Russia having a very cunning plan to win the battle and possibly win the war. It’s so cunning, in fact, that even Zettour doesn’t pick up on it, which leaves Tanya and company in a bit of a pickle, since they’re soldiers, and it’s bad form to do things without actual orders. Unfortunately, without orders, they’ll all die.

The Empire (including the Emperor and the royal family, who we’ve seen little of in this series) are expecting a fantastic victory from the Empire’s glorious military. The glorious military, unfortunately, is rapidly realizing that everything hinges on Zettour, and that’s bad, because if anything happens to him, the entire war collapses. Meanwhile, Tanya and her crew are back on the Eastern Front, and are somewhat disturbed by how… quiet it is. Technically this is good, right? It means that, as they thought, the Federation is not going to attack till at least spring. They *do* find a mage battalion, but they’re all weak and are taken out super easily. Everything’s coming up roses… so why is Tanya’s danger sense tingling? As it turns out, she’s 100% correct, and the Empire is now facing an unprecedented attack along the ENTIRE front. They need immediate orders to retreat or they’ll all be slaughtered. Unfortunately, the general at the front is MIA. What can Tanya do?

I was delighted to see a lot of Visha in this book. Let’s face it, I can do without Tanya talking about military history and what a good, kind person she is for 380 pages a pop, but give me some of Visha being the happiest adjutant around and I’m fine. I still suspect that all of Tanya’s unit except Tanya are going to die before the series ends, but hope springs eternal. As for the plot itself, well, not to spoil too much, but the climax of this volume relies on Tanya having to essentially do something that would normally get her court-martialed and executed (Bruce McCandless is mentioned) but, because she’s surrounded by people who trust her utterly, she’s able to do it. Given the whole “The Evil” designation for this series – and don’t get me wrong, she’s committed atrocities – it’s startling how she’s (presumably, hi, cliffhanger) able to survive here because her command group have all been with her for years and know what she’s capable of. Now – will it work?

Probably, but things are STILL going very badly for the Empire. Assuming you can get past the dense prose, this is still interesting. If you can’t, the manga reads better and also has more than two women in it.

Spy Classroom Short Story Collection: Honeymoon Raker

Leave a reply

By Takemachi and Tomari. Released in Japan as “Spy Kyoushitsu” by Fujimi Fantasia Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Nathaniel Hiroshi Thrasher.

I’ve mentioned before that Spy Classroom drops far more short story volumes than most light novel series. This is the third, and there’s a fourth one coming after the next main volume in the series. The short story collections all take their subtitles from James Bond films, and this one is no exception. This one also has a purpose: just as the 2nd SS book had all the Lily stuff that the author had to cut out of the 4th book, this has all the bonding between Lamplight and Avian that had to be removed from the 5th. Which means, yes, it’s one last round for Avian, who have now been dead for five books but keep coming back for more punishment nevertheless. Of course, they’re all alive here, and since we already saw them abusing our heroines in the main series, these are a far more gentle series of short stories… mostly. Towards the end, we finally get to see exactly how Avian died, and it’s just as brutal as you’d expect.

The “honeymoon” part of the book just means that this takes place when Avian are in between missions and freeloading at Lamplight HQ, leading to the following short stories: 1) Pharma uses the three youngest members of Lamplight to catch a pedophile politician, much to Sara’s horror (she is one of the three); 2) Lan tries to avoid getting killed by Annette for calling her a “runt” in the main series, and also tries to catch a member of a gang of ex-spies, with Monica’s help… sort of; 3) Annette is trying to get a stray cat she saw in the alley by the docks to open up to her, and Queneau is there to tell her it’ll never happen as long as Annette is the way she is; 4) Avian continue to try to catch the ex-spies, as well as continuing to try to get one over on Klaus, but are horrified to find Lamplight are better at that than they are; 5) everyone comes together – if only by accident – to take on the leaders of the ex-spies; and 6) Avian gets brutally slaughtered, leading to Book 6 of the main series.

I’ve already said that Sara is my favorite character, but Annette may be the most interesting character, if only as she has the farthest to go in terms of character development. Her story may be the most predictable in this book (also, content alert, there are murdered animals in this part), but it’s also the most needed, as she’s told point blank that she needs to “alter her nature” in order to obtain her goals. Annette experiences loss here for possibly the first time she’s conscious of, and I wonder if it will impact her going forward. Most of these stories are an inverse of the 5th book, which was there to show us why Lamplight were so bad compared to Avian. Here we see, in cases other than pure combat, Lamplight have better teamwork and better planning, mostly as Avian doesn’t work as a team but as a bunch of folks who work together. They almost manage to get past this… before that ending.

Each of the SS collections has been better than the previous, which pleases me. Next time we’re back to the main story, which apparently starts its third arc.